Google 
85 reviews
4.9/5 average rating
Mary Habashi
Eddie Hilaire
"Always fresh hot food. Delivery is always within ETA"
5 years ago
Google review
Peter Gowman
"Great Pizza, Excellent customer service."
5 years ago
Google review
Lucy Rodrigues
"The best pizza in the area."
5 years ago
Google review
John Gill
"Excellent pizzas"
5 years ago
Google review
Sean Smith
"This pizza shop is off it's head, perfection 👌🏽"
5 years ago
Google review
Sarah Butler
"This is some excellent pizza and pasta and is consistently good. Way better than any of the pizza chains. Great value as well."
6 years ago
Google review
Abdul
"Best pizza and service in the area"
6 years ago
Google review
sydney t
"Tasty food 👌 love it ."
6 years ago
Google review
Mario Kolotas
"I have a terrible experience with Menulog tonight but as usual the pizzas were delicious. I also would like to thank the restaurant for understanding my frustration and delivering my order once again after they originally sent it but due to the incompetence of Menulog and there driver my order was given away to some people. But thanks to the guys at Fat Tony..." Read more
6 years ago
Google review
Steph Moore
"Ordered on Uber eats. By far the most incredible service and delicious pizza EVER!!!! We order no cheese and didn’t have cheese apparently this is hard for everyone else!!! And also extra crispy which was! Absolutely incredible thank you so much 🙌🏼🙌🏼"
6 years ago
Google review
Ashlea Byrd
"Ordered a medium supreme & medium chicken tandoori pizza for myself and husband tonight to share. Sooo good and so filling, we couldnt even finish a pizza between us! Definitely going to order again when we are back in the area!!"
6 years ago
Google review
John Tait
"Absolute cracker of pizza! I was a pizza chef for 9 years and in my time ive only come across a handful of worthy pizzas. Fat Tonys presents a pizza worth trying. In the 2km radius it wipes the rest off the map!"
6 years ago
Google review
Coin Man
"Pizza was delish"
6 years ago
Google review
Pariya Singhanatnitirak
"Highly recommend this local Italian food store. Love the friendly service and delicious food. Thanks guys will be back"
7 years ago
Google review
Nat M
"I can’t say anything bad about this place!! HANDS DOWN THE BEST IN SOUTH WEST SYDNEY 😍😍 the food is to die for!!!"
7 years ago
Google review
Mani L
"Food was great, authentic tasting Italian pizza & pasta. There was a slight variation in price from the menulog app to the instore price."
7 years ago
Google review
Tony Doyle
"Pizza's have been great + garlic pizza number 2 fantastic"
7 years ago
Google review
Dane William
"Best pizza in the area by miles. Won't be going anywhere else for pizza from now on. Fast service, and really tasty pizzas with lots of toppings unlike other stores nearby. They are part of Menulog or you can get delivery direct from the store."
8 years ago
Google review
Alyssa Crofts
"OMG These pizzas are beautiful. To die for. Mouth watering. Highly recommend Fat Tobys Pizza to everyone over Dominos and Pizza Hut. Forget about the price. Money is well worth these pizzas."
8 years ago
Google review
Chandre Kroutz
"Excellent food excellent service !"
8 years ago
Google review
Paul Harper
"Very good"
8 years ago
Google review
Isaac Jarv
"Best Pizza in west Sydney.Great pasta options too!"
8 years ago
Google review
Hamm Sandwich
"Fat Tony's pizza and pasta is simply delicious. The pizzas come in four sizes ( small, medium, large and family) and they offer gluten free bases aswell. The pastas are very tasty, the portions will serve 2 adults. The staff are friendly and the service is quick. The only negative thing i have experienced related to Fat Tony's is regarding the online ord..." Read more
8 years ago
Google review
Bernie Mundweil
"Best Pizza in Sydney"
8 years ago
Google review
"Recently moved into the area and ordered from here twice already. Delicious pizzas! Generous with their toppings and very tasty. Our new go-to for local Italian food"
5 years ago