TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,210 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
Mott
Kaleb Blotske
"Never written a review before but the pizza was so bad I had too. Not even half cooked"
4 years ago
Google review
Lance Porter
"By not accepting cash anymore, you’re also not accepting my business. Genius move."
4 years ago
Google review
Robert Buda
"The pizza was horrible and all the ingredients were not cooked. Any frozen pizza from the grocery store is better than this"
4 years ago
Google review
T K
"Worst pizza I've ever had. Went in, first time ordering here, saw old pizza on racks and commented to my family "look at the old gross pizza" thinking maybe they were for display. Cold congealed cheese, dry, guess what pizza I got..? They are reheated pizzas. They prep them, leave them out, then add toppings and reheat when you order it. The crust was crunch..." Read more
4 years ago
Google review
Tricia Atanasio
"Pick whether you are going to be open or close the whole South Fargo place down, because what you have going on now with open/close and no notice is completely ridiculous."
4 years ago
Google review
Soy Boy
"I knew what was happening after my very first bite: This place pre-bakes pizzas throughout the day, then refrigerates them and bakes them again as they're ordered. I'm sure the toppings are fresh, but when it comes to pizza you can just taste quality and freshness more than you can with many other foods. I'd say your best bet if you want to eat here would..." Read more
4 years ago
Google review
Travis Orth
"I’ve ordered from spicy pie before and it used to be good then it started to go down hill so I stopped ordering from them. So after about a year, tonight I ordered a Mac and cheese pizza and a pepperoni pizza. Let me start of by saying the Mac and cheese pizza was very dry and seemed like it had been sitting for awhile and the Mac and cheese on it was so muc..." Read more
4 years ago
Google review
Joshua Wesaw
"If you like thin crust go here. I don't though."
4 years ago
Google review
Brock Lane
"Came in 20 minutes before closing and couldn’t get no service! Asked bar tender he looked at his watch looked at the kitchen then went in there and never came back ! Will never be going here again"
4 years ago
Google review
Food Porn Of America
"Barley any sauce, very little cheese. Over all not good."
4 years ago
Google review
Melissa Baya
"Hello all! I feel the need to share about my horrid experience with the N. Broadway Spicy Pie, and the shift supervisor, Danielle. I order delivery from this Spicy Pie 2-4 times wkly, every week (I like my food 🤷🤣) However, tonight I was refused delivery by Danielle - who said they cannot deliver to me anymore bc of complaints. WHAT??? The only complain..." Read more
4 years ago
Google review
Mike Dunn
"Definitely the worst pizza I've had in Minot. Customer service is about as bad as I've experienced also. Undercover boss needed for this place."
4 years ago
Google review
Mariam Almozrouei
"My husband ordered a pizza without bacon, and they put bacon, when we called about it they said “sometimes we don’t have the best people working here” 🙄."
4 years ago
Google review
Alicia Waters
"If you are looking for a New York slice this is not it, I keep trying to give this place the benefit of the doubt, but if you have a craving for a great slice that you used to be able to get on any street THIS IS NOT IT! It might be the best the Midwest can offer, but this is not what you are craving :("
4 years ago
Google review
Scorpios Fire
"Make sure u like stone pizza. Bread stick bites are seasoned extremely strong, thick and doughy. If that's yr taste."
5 years ago
Google review
Your Daily Dose
"If you want very undercooked pizza go here. Here, ill save you some cash. Use code 8228 on pizzahut for 5.99 1 toppings, you might not think it's as good as this place but they'll at least cook it."
5 years ago
Google review
Sportsman Nate
"this place is overpriced and run by lazy lazy people!! their employees don't care about the product that they serve. It is way overpriced!! I went from going to this place 3-4 times a week to 1-2 times per year now. Every time we have gone in the last two years it has been a bad experience, the kids won't eat Spicy Pie anymore. It's very simple, Spicy Pie, t..." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
aic rules
"Over rated and dry crust."
5 years ago
Google review
M B
"Trying to find good pizza in Minot. Tried 3 places so far. Spicy Pie pizza was the worst we've ever had. Guess we have to wait until we can go back to Italy in order to get real pizza."
5 years ago
Google review
JA S
"Ordered the pepperoni and mushroom pizza. Not crispy, bland seasoning, just overall blah... I live in Central Florida and I almost felt like dejavu when I worked in a nursing home kitchen while going to college 25+ years ago (this is kind of what they served).... if college kids call that pizza here, I feel sorry for them...."
5 years ago
Google review
Danny Montana
"Was not at Spicy Pie, today or ever"
5 years ago
Google review
TJC
"Horrible owner=horrible restaurants. Nothing is EPIC about these places."
5 years ago
Google review
Lindsay Garner
"Zero stars! Drama"
5 years ago
Google review
Sylvester Sloth
"I witnessed a, what I assume to be, supervisor yell at an employee when she was just doing her job. The food was good, but after seeing that, I don't believe I want to eat there anymore."
5 years ago
Google review
"SO DRY!! Dryer than the Sahara desert. Where that sauce at? Each slice had about 1 milliliter of sauce!!"
4 years ago