Google 
TripAdvisor 
Kristen Erickson
Gregory Scarbrough
"I tried the downtown location after living in the area for 2 years and grown up on the chains and the occasional mom and pop places in other states.The cashier was nice, however the $30 pizza (macaroni and bacon) left a lot to be desired. It sounded tasty online only to be bland in person with bland pre made macaroni and cheese with no flavor and bacon being..." Read more
12 days ago
Google review
Tom Taylor
"By far, one of the best pizza places in the Fargo- Moorhead area. Great selection and the staff is friendly and helpful. The pizza is amazing, reminiscent of the pizza I've had in NYC. Truly a place for the whole family."
13 days ago
Google review
JENNIFER WILDER
"It was the most bland, nothing-good-to-even-mention pizza I've ever had. Skimpy on ALL the toppings/ingredients.. couldn't, i even tell if there was sauce on it. Won't be ordering again."
25 days ago
Google review
david spencer
"45 minutes for disgusting food. This place sucks"
a month ago
Google review
Rusty Krall
"Always good food and service completely satisfied"
a month ago
Google review
kevin mcdonald
"We Love Spicy pie, but in the last 6 months it’s really gone down hill!! Pretty sad when you order a pizza and have to take it home and add more ingredients. Not hardly any sauce at all and very little ingredients. Guess we’ll have to go back to planet pizza. Very sad!"
2 months ago
Google review
Justin Helgeson
"The pizza was great. Would recommend!"
2 months ago
Google review
1Q_& iiivi
"Don't tell but I joint the club an got a colossal mega jumbo slice of the month & soda for $3-4ish bucks! Steal of a deal an all was finger licking split quick."
2 months ago
Google review
Brandee Hahn
"Absolutly the best pizza ever!!"
3 months ago
Google review
Josh Lutter
"Food was great. Pretty good sale if you did the 2 single top slices and a drink for 11 bucks. I opted to try the Buffalo chicken though. Crust is great, sauce is great, toppings are great. Definitely hit the spot and would be happy to come back next time in town. I really enjoy the big slices over a personal pan."
3 months ago
Google review
Greyson Connolly
"Only reason they got 3 stars is because it's become incredibly expensive since the last time I went, staff and everything else was just fine"
4 months ago
Google review
Segos Wood
"Unfortunately it was a major disappointment. The dough was not cooked all the way. I asked to see if it was just grease that caused it to be so chewy. They weren't sure so they cooked it again then made the rest of the pizza almost like microwave chewy. I guess they don't precook the dough before putting all the toppings on it. The cashier did not know what..." Read more
4 months ago
Google review
Eric N
"Place used to be amazing. They seem to be having a tough time financially, and now starting to see price increases and credit card fee collections on top of that. I was a loyal customer, but nickel and dime your customers to pay a credit card fee is not a good customer experience. Last time I was in, I went to grab a beer while I waited for my order, the loc..." Read more
4 months ago
Google review
Mr Tupac
"Decent pizza made by teenagers for an outrageous price."
4 months ago
Google review
Dragon
"Although Casey's pizza has my heart, my number one side piece is spicy pie. Great options, nice staff and interesting decor."
4 months ago
Google review
TravelbugUSA
"Huge pizza! Thin crust and just the right amount of sauce!"
4 months ago
Google review
Tom Harrell
"Wow,got chips and dip delivered with almost all whole chips.The bone in buffalo wings are awesome.Got two slices of Hawaiian with buffaloes wings and chips delivered for 30 buck plus tip and I am completely blown away by the quality and flavor."
4 months ago
Google review
Jonah “Chief black wolf” Plenty chief
"Dining in you'll love the atmosphere and the vibes the music it's a great spot for pizza - The service they provide is PHENOMENAL! ask about the BBQ chicken flat bread so good it mite as well be the chronic ! If u love your family friends and ur lady or man u better bring em here u won't regret"
4 months ago
Google review
Matt Condon
"Pizza was bad. Crust tasted like cardboard, made me sick. Would not recommend. Way too expensive"
5 months ago
Google review
Roy Thomsen
"Bought my daughter a gift card, it’s older than the 5 year ND law, and she tried to use it, and they declined it, stating “we don’t have to because it’s the law.” It has $12.85 on it. Card does not have an expiration date on it. Literally not worth the time for the amount on the card, but the rudeness and principle behind it, and the fact the manager wouldn’..." Read more
5 months ago
Google review
Laura Schnieber
"Very very clean and polite staff!"
5 months ago
Google review
Michelle P.
"NASTY NO FLAVOR! OMG R U KIDDING ME YOU LET YOU HALF COOKED PUZZA SIT FOR HOURS THEN PUT TOPPINGS ON N COOK MORE CAN WE SAY GROSS N FOOD PIOSONING IM AFRAID TO EAT THIS!!!! AND ITS BURNT ON THE BOTYOM NEVER AGSIN I just paid $6 for sliced pizza. I'm so disgusted out BY I can eat"
5 months ago
Google review
Tina Regstad
"2 people at my table received their slice of pizza…we waited & waited for the 3rd. Asked them about the order..said it was coming…waited another 15 minutes…FINALLY got the order! SAME thing happened last time we were there! Won’t be back!"
6 months ago
Google review
Jana Rae Photography
"The best pizza in the Fargo Moorhead area!"
6 months ago
Google review
"I really like the pizza but the slowness is just astounding. We don’t make it here very often maybe once or twice a year and every time we wait an hour plus for pizza. Trying to get a beverage I’ve always had to go to the bar. I get it, trying to find good help is hard, but not once did we have anyone stop at our table, and one of the orders didn’t have the..." Read more
10 days ago