TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,173 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
john ness
Andrew Rostad
"Pizza used to be great but it’s really gone down hill in the past year or so. It’s all crust and little to no toppings. Tried to give them a few more chances but it just keeps getting worse."
7 years ago
Google review
Rachael Wessman
"Pizza came very quickly which we were happy about. However, the pizza was basically flipped over in the box and all of the toppings fell off and were up against the side of the box. We also never received the white sauce we asked for. I’m not sure if our deliver girl slipped on ice and that’s why it was all over the place. I’ll give the place another try but..." Read more
7 years ago
Google review
Shelby Beeter
"Ordered 3 slices of pizza to my school (souris river) its been almost an hour spicy pie is a straight line maybe 6 blocks from here. Wouldnt recommend ordering delivery."
7 years ago
Google review
Youness Himmi
"Ordered a slice of meat lovers pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was cold, the meat and cheese just clumped together and fell off of the slice when I tried to take a bite. The garlic knots should be called garlic buns, no knots at all. Tried this place twice and both times it was a pretty bad experience, the food is just lousy here."
7 years ago
Google review
Aly Miller
"If you order delivery be prepared to wait a long time. They tell you 45 minutes but their actual delivery time is 45 minutes to an hour and a half. I waited almost two hours to get my pizza"
7 years ago
Google review
Vicki Nordman
"Saturday night busy but should be prepared. Asked to order knots, said they were out. Wings. . . Said too busy! Looked like plenty of staff. Seemed disorganized. Losing business! With family from out of town. Very disappointing 😩"
7 years ago
Google review
Jeffrey Blaseg
"Terrible, terrible food. My taco salad came with basically one scoop of ground beef in it, a handful of assorted veggies and then a majority of it was stale gross lettuce. My boyfriend had one of the Grinder sandwiches which was equally as bad - it was pretty much a hamburger with some meat sauce thrown on top with melted cheese. The only saving grace was th..." Read more
7 years ago
Google review
Heidi Klein
"Good food, but the process to get the food is way under par. Server was at our table five different times before were finally had everything... had to be reminded what we were missing. Never got our cinnamon knots, ever, even after asking. Another person joined us, after 45 minutes he inquired about his order, apparently the couldn't find his number..." Read more
7 years ago
Google review
Ryan Harmon
"Good pizza, decent prices, terrible delivery. More often than not it looks like the driver took the pie on a roller coaster. If you're gonna get spicy pie, dine in or carry out."
7 years ago
Google review
MS81
"I had ordered delivery at 10:08 pm. Called at 11:08 pm because the order still hadn't shown up. I was told it would be another 30 min due to their driver. The order did not arrive until 11:20 pm and the pizzas were cold. The employee said they were sorry and were going to comp the order, that never happened."
8 years ago
Google review
Marlene Hershberger
"Pizza has potential... Crust is good but a little over cooked, which could've been masked if the proper amount of sauce was on the pizza, but due to minimal sauce the over cooked crust made it very dry. Feeling disappointed was looking forward to great Sunday afternoon pizza."
8 years ago
Google review
Pete V
"Not very well organized"
8 years ago
Google review
Keri Crewson
"Horrible service in restaurant."
8 years ago
Google review
Scott Walters
"Go somewhere else for your pizza by the slice. The service was a bit slow and inaccurate. I ordered one kind of beer and they brought a different one. The food is nothing special. Not bad, but you can definitely find better."
8 years ago
Google review
Brian Bjugstad
"I did not like their pizza. It could be good but the whole par baking then adding topping on top turned me off. Admittedly I have not been here in a couple years. The grinder was ok though."
8 years ago
Google review
Ben W Gunter
"A little high priced and I expected more, like sauce and toppings to the outside. Very little sauce and toppings bunched in the middle..what a waste"
8 years ago
Google review
Jacob Mischel
"This is the second week in a row that my order has been forgotten after 40mins over lunch. It wasn't terribly busy, but I still had to bother the cashier as to where the order was. After she dug through a stack of reciepts, I finally got my food. All in all, the food is great. The service at this location in particular is terrible."
8 years ago
Google review
Nicholas Peckham (Nicko)
"Pizza is not that good which is disappointing because this place is a pizza spot. On the flip side you can get some good deals on slices if you like paying for cheap, low quality pizza."
9 years ago
Google review
Moira Evanden
"I was very disappointed. I ordered nachoes and a sandwich online. The website gave a projected delivery of 45 minutes and it took more than twice that to arrive. I called the restaurant 4 times and was unable to get anyone to answer the phone to ask what was going on. The delivery boy was very terse. By time I got the food, it was cold. The nachoes were very..." Read more
9 years ago
Google review
Phil White
"2 stars. GREAT FOOD!!! No question about that. Customer service, well, let's just say when your order is incorrect upon delivery it is considered your fault and you will have to argue with "a manager" to get the delivery fee removed in order to get the correct order delivered. It is not like we were trying to get anything free just not charged for their mist..." Read more
9 years ago
Google review
Andrew B (darth taters)
"I want to love Spicy Pie. I honestly do. They have the hip/urban decor, the NY-style pizza, the fantastic downtown location...but the pizza is just bad. I've tried time and time again to turn my opinion around on this place, but every time I stop in I regret it. The crust is consistently burnt black and the cheese and sauce are practically nonexistent, leav..." Read more
11 years ago
Google review
Rachel Knight
"Horrible service and even more horrible food"
12 years ago
Google review
Beau Lundmark
"The sauce tasted like ketchup and tomatoe paste. That was the most flavorful part of the pizza."
13 years ago
Google review
"Only eat in at this location. Delivery service is terrible. Have tried it twice and both times the food was cold. This last time it took two hours to make it with my nachos. Eating at the location the food is wonderful. Only reason they get two stars. Great place to eat but delivery service is the worst."
7 years ago