TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,210 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
Amber Ray
Lexi Hunt
"Stopped at this place for a band thing at the college and goodness gracious… I got a jumbo slice of pepperoni pizza with a fountain coke and it was absolutely scrumptious. The pepperonis were as big as a slice of summer sausage and it was so good, I almost cried. The ranch was also absolutely yummy. Plus, it was only $7 for it and well worth it because I wil..." Read more
4 years ago
Google review
Suman Koirala
"This is an amazing pizza place in downtown Fargo. The giant New York style slices are affordable and amazing. The vibe is nice and cozy. This is one of the go to lunch place for me with my coworkers."
4 years ago
Google review
Elisabeth S
"I go here for the red sauce"
4 years ago
Google review
Rachel
"Good pizza at a reasonable price. Nice lunch specials too."
4 years ago
Google review
McKinlee Harmon
"Best place I’ve ever been in my life."
4 years ago
Google review
Matthew Splichal
"Amazing restaurant, huge pizza and wall art!"
4 years ago
Google review
Morgen Ruth
"I've never heard or been to this place before and thought I'd give it a shot for lunch. Man, SO good! I've been so used to places like Domino's that I forgot how good a "home made" crust tasted like. Cheese tasted like real cheese too. It was so good, my wife and I ate an entire 18" cheese. FYI when you get a pizza, they're all 18". In my mind, that makes th..." Read more
4 years ago
Google review
Andy Christophersin
"Great pizza pies greater deals"
4 years ago
Google review
Steven Rose
"Great food and service!"
4 years ago
Google review
Fargo's Folly
"Nice place to get a quick meal. Slices are about $5, but they are HUGE."
4 years ago
Google review
Dan Quaas
"Can't go wrong at Spicy Pie. Always a favorite when visiting our boys in college."
4 years ago
Google review
Jeff Doerr
"Loved it! Great lunch choice, staff extremely friendly and polite. Value based and quality driven! Thank you Spicy Pie."
4 years ago
Google review
Kristi Stelzner
"There food is good and it never take long"
4 years ago
Google review
Miquela Scott
"Great food!"
4 years ago
Google review
Anton Ward
"Great restaurant with amazing employees. I also ordered a single slice to try the food and it was great as well. All around great experience would highly recommend."
4 years ago
Google review
Hana M
"The food here are surprisingly good. Affordable price , good location and friendly staff. I ordered the one with all the meats on it, love it. If we visit Fargo again, we will be back."
4 years ago
Google review
Maren Wakefield
"Tasty pizza and you can still get a pitcher of beer with it!"
4 years ago
Google review
Will Larson
"Great tasting slice - some flop, good ratio of sauce, plenty of cheese. Good crust. Score of an 8.3 - and that’s my review"
4 years ago
Google review
Rob
"Brought my niece who was up from Florida. She loved her slice! I had the special of the month (Nov 2021) was amazing. Great service and great comfort food."
4 years ago
Google review
Brandon Nelson
"Simply the best in ND! Great Pizza!"
4 years ago
Google review
B Ray
"Great pizza!! Cool place!"
4 years ago
Google review
Maggie Morrison (MggieSenpai)
"Delicious! I love coming here, love by the slice pizza places. Their selection is amazing. Sometimes a little slow, but well worth the wait!"
4 years ago
Google review
Damian Vincent
"Great"
4 years ago
Google review
Jordan Anderson
"Super fast and friendly service. The pizza was great with super large portions."
4 years ago
Google review
"We visited from Florida for a hockey tournament! We loved it! Great pizza!"
4 years ago