TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,168 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
Devon Olson
Kelly Barbot
"Clean establishment and nice staff. Faster service than their downtown location and better seating. Love the outdoor option."
8 years ago
Google review
Daryle Mindeman
"Love the walls in this place."
8 years ago
Google review
J M
"It's a fun college pizza joint with a more than average menu. It also has decent bar selection. I ate in, and had a grinder and pizza slice. The grinder was excellent, the slice was average NY style. I imagine a fresh pie would be better. The service was great, and I will be back."
8 years ago
Google review
Jason G
"Good place to get pizza by the slice"
8 years ago
Google review
Alistair Houpe
"Everytime I come to mine not I come to the spicy pie and enjoy the pizza the company the atmosphere and the customer service nice place"
8 years ago
Google review
Kyle Nordick
"Great pizza, 18" pies only. Also have tacos, grinder, full bar. Try some grinder side on your pizza."
8 years ago
Google review
James Gienger
"Very good lots of cheese and Topping's !😍😀"
8 years ago
Google review
Aaron Waite
"This place is a nice downtown pizza joint to go to. They have good options of pizza and beer. Nice inviting atmosphere."
8 years ago
Google review
John Beach
"Drastic turn around in both quality and customer service! Bread bites are the best thing I the menu!"
8 years ago
Google review
Dale Murphy
"Friendly staff, good food, and cool tables."
8 years ago
Google review
C Strand
"Pizza is similar to what you would find in New York. One of our favorite places to go. Try the ultimate grinder."
8 years ago
Google review
Alex Gackle
"Staff suck. The pizza is good though."
8 years ago
Google review
Nick Post
"I love the food, but the prices have been climbing noticeably for a while. I'm not sure the reasons, but it's not cool."
9 years ago
Google review
Spencer
"Pizza is great, but service is lethargic. If the service was faster and it was a bit cheaper, I'd give them five stars."
9 years ago
Google review
K Conti
"Ive never had a problem with the place. Pizza of the month is always kick ass too."
9 years ago
Google review
Alex Hatzenbuhler
"Spicy pie has excellent pizza, but this location isn't up to the same standard of service as other locations. It's usually pretty busy on weeknights, but it always seems to be slower than expected. I've also noticed that it can be dirty during busy hours. Still great food though!"
9 years ago
Google review
Blair Briggs
"It started as the only place i know of to order pizza by the slice in Fargo (NY style). Later came the tacos and grinders (compete with white sauce like Red Pepper). Always a fun experience with good food. A good place to take the family."
9 years ago
Google review
Jimmy Joyner
"Good"
9 years ago
Google review
Zach Priddy
"Great food great price"
10 years ago
Google review
Matt McQuigg
"Good food, nice people"
10 years ago
Google review
Ian Berdanier
"I'm from PA, so I know a good Philly cheese steak and pizza made right, both of which are hard to find in places outside the northeastern U.S. So I was surprised to find pizza this good in North Dakota. I liked the taco salad too (with the shell in the salad instead of the salad in the shell)."
10 years ago
Google review
michael bohn
"Red dough ?"
10 years ago
Google review
Matt Turner
"People were nice there and it was cool to see the crust being hand made right next to the ordering counter. We ordered on one half of the pizza just cheese and pepperoni and the other half with cheese, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, and jalapenos. The kids enjoyed the pepperoni side but my wife and I loved the other side. The toppings were fresh and the p..." Read more
12 years ago
Google review
Kalene Sharstrom
"I enjoy going to Spicy Pie on occasion. We usually have a good experience with food quality, and when we did have a bad slice, it was immediately corrected. But the service is rather on the sluggish side, especially during busy times. It is a small sized restaurant (just a bit larger than JL Beers) so if you are coming in with a big group, plan ahead to grab..." Read more
12 years ago
Google review
"I like it just wish there was more cheese on the pizza."
7 years ago