Spicy Pie Reviews & Testimonials

3.9 (1,191)

Google Reviews: 1,173


5
53%
4
19%
3
8%
2
6%
1
13%

72% of Google users would recommend Spicy Pie

  1,173 reviews
  3.9/5 average rating

  Showing 2 star reviews only  

B

B star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Pizza has no flavor even with toppings, taste like thin cardboard. Got two slices and only could choke down half of one. It would help if they put some sauce on it.."

2 months ago

Google review

iMbue (iMbue)

iMbue (iMbue) star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"D- pizza might as well be raw. Wrong crust type. Basically an insult to pizza. Saw in an ad NY style pizza and that comparison is offensive. I could have cooked it better in an easy-bake oven with the light bulb barely working. Atmosphere was ok and pizza was on time (likely because of all the time they saved not cooking it)"

4 months ago

Google review

Ivy Barrels

Ivy Barrels star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Pizza was just ok. I guess I've had worse. Too greasy and the bacon was too salty. Slow service, too"

4 months ago

Google review

Tim Behrens- Lefty guitar

Tim Behrens- Lefty guitar star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Greasy pile of glop."

4 months ago

Google review

Derrick M70

Derrick M70 star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"By all accounts it should be a cool place with great pizza. All attempts at trendy point that way but the pizza is barely bar worthy. Somehow the crust is burnt and not done at the same time. Floppy sloppy greasy cardboard made too big and hard to eat. I guess locals like it but if you're in from out of town don't bother. There's gotta be better. I get th..." Read more

5 months ago

Google review

David Nold

David Nold star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Poor pizza. Way overpriced. Go elsewhere."

6 months ago

Google review

Kristen Erickson

Kristen Erickson star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"I really like the pizza but the slowness is just astounding. We don’t make it here very often maybe once or twice a year and every time we wait an hour plus for pizza. Trying to get a beverage I’ve always had to go to the bar. I get it, trying to find good help is hard, but not once did we have anyone stop at our table, and one of the orders didn’t have the..." Read more

8 months ago

Google review

kevin mcdonald

kevin mcdonald star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"We Love Spicy pie, but in the last 6 months it’s really gone down hill!! Pretty sad when you order a pizza and have to take it home and add more ingredients. Not hardly any sauce at all and very little ingredients. Guess we’ll have to go back to planet pizza. Very sad!"

10 months ago

Google review

Eric N

Eric N star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Place used to be amazing. They seem to be having a tough time financially, and now starting to see price increases and credit card fee collections on top of that. I was a loyal customer, but nickel and dime your customers to pay a credit card fee is not a good customer experience. Last time I was in, I went to grab a beer while I waited for my order, the loc..." Read more

a year ago

Google review

Mr Tupac

Mr Tupac star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Decent pizza made by teenagers for an outrageous price."

a year ago

Google review

Jake Stclaire

Jake Stclaire star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Not a fan."

2 years ago

Google review

55 555

55 555 star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"The pizza is good but the music they play is too loud. This isn't a nightclub. Turn it down."

2 years ago

Google review

Ted Hoselton

Ted Hoselton star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Wouldn’t accept cash for delivery. The total was less then $22"

2 years ago

Google review

Hazel Naanes

Hazel Naanes star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"I never had a problem waiting for my food here until recently. I ordered a single slice of pizza that ended up taking an hour. Staff were nice enough, but it still doesn't excuse the absurd amount of time. Disappointed and won't be returning for awhile."

2 years ago

Google review

Guido N

Guido N star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Sorry, tried it twice. Horrible crust, and each time under baked."

2 years ago

Google review

Dave Mann

Dave Mann star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Did not eat here for a long time. Decided to give it another try and order delivery. The pizza was giant as promised, however it was overcooked and I could have used the outer two inches of crust as a hammer. Very little toppings and flavorless. Arrived way later than was expected. If your looking for a pizza place, consider somewhere else.... anywhere e..." Read more

2 years ago

Google review

Nikki Nogowski

Nikki Nogowski star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"mediocre at best. I have a gift card they wouldn't allow me to use saying it didn't have funds, so I pulled up the website that shows the gift card balance and showed them that it has $25. I was told that there was nothing they could do and I was given a number to call Lexi regarding the gift card issue. I called and left her a voicemail 2 days ago and still..." Read more

2 years ago

Google review

Jonathan Klein

Jonathan Klein star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Wasn't great not much for toppings or sauce. Some of the pizza was not cooked well. First time coming here. The staff was helpful. I've had way better pizza at a truck stop. Price for one topping with coke was 23.00"

3 years ago

Google review

Jayson Pasch

Jayson Pasch star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Nice place; pizza was ready fast. The pizza had little no flavor as far as the cheese, pretty much no sauce, cheese was under cooked. Not sure if I'll go back."

3 years ago

Google review

M T

M T star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Thier pisa was good but not anymore."

3 years ago

Google review

Raymond Salazar

Raymond Salazar star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Idk why this is a four-star restaurant I’m giving two stars for effort"

3 years ago

Google review

Isaac Karlstrom

Isaac Karlstrom star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Over rated. Just subpar"

3 years ago

Google review

Nate Ray

Nate Ray star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Slow service and my order has never not gotten lost."

4 years ago

Google review

Kelly Gallegos

Kelly Gallegos star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Pizza wasn't too bad, place looked fun with all of the visual items but customer service was lacking! I stood at the counter for a long time and no one greeted me until asked where do we order. There were alot of employees behind the counter making the food and no one acknowledged me. After I paid I said thank you and the lady didnt say thank you back. W..." Read more

4 years ago

Google review

J Fajardo

J Fajardo star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Amazing staff and ambiance but the food was horrible :( Not worth the money."

4 years ago

Google review