TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,210 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
That guy that travels a bit
Nathan Gange
"The pie is great, but why do you start kicking everyone out at 2045, when you close at 2200. Doesn't make sense. Should definitely do better management. You are losing money."
7 months ago
Google review
John Eaton
"Tried contacting through you site… I went to the fair today the magiccon and I was looking forward to getting some pizza with my little girl. You had one slice of cheese left for her and I asked if another one’s coming out and I was told they’re not gonna put any more out until the other others Have been sold. I would’ve gotten two additional slices that yo..." Read more
7 months ago
Google review
Marvin Calice
"The pizza is the closest to New York style you can find around here. Years ago, I loved this place and got pies here all the time. But why pay double for something similar."
7 months ago
Google review
Heather Griffith
"Called in an order while in town visiting and arrived one minute after it was done. Staff were busy talking to each other in the kitchen, even looked up at me, but didn’t say anything. By time I got my pizza it was cold. It was an average pie. Looks like a fun spot to hang out at though! Arcade games for kids and gambling spots for adults"
9 months ago
Google review
Greyson Connolly
"Only reason they got 3 stars is because it's become incredibly expensive since the last time I went, staff and everything else was just fine"
2 years ago
Google review
Segos Wood
"Unfortunately it was a major disappointment. The dough was not cooked all the way. I asked to see if it was just grease that caused it to be so chewy. They weren't sure so they cooked it again then made the rest of the pizza almost like microwave chewy. I guess they don't precook the dough before putting all the toppings on it. The cashier did not know what..." Read more
2 years ago
Google review
Tj Reyes
"If you like bread, you'll love it here! They only have one size pizza or you can order slices. They have wings that don't taste very good. They actually taste cheap and very fatty. They have nachos that taste SUPER bland. I guess their beef has never seen spice before. Their pizza is ok. Nothing to write home about. To be called spicy pie and there is nothin..." Read more
2 years ago
Google review
Karli Brekke
"Great pizza like always, but wow was it littered with flies and gnats in there. My husband and I couldn’t even sit down for more than a minute without swatting them away. It was pretty frustrating as it didn’t seem like they had a handle on the situation."
2 years ago
Google review
Nicoh Ross
"I love the food here, but the service is definitely hit or miss. You order something and they bring you something vastly different and make no effort to correct the flaw."
2 years ago
Google review
Tim Drake
"Fairly decent New York-style pizza served by the pie or by the slice. I like that they serve the slice option. I tried a slice of pepperoni and their cheese curd pizza. Both were good, but not as great as I had hoped for. They also serve grinders and garlic knots and the restaurant also has a bar."
2 years ago
Google review
Francis Froehlich
"Fast pizza type food. it's pretty good for pizza."
3 years ago
Google review
Ben Buchmiller
"My wife went here and got the bacon Mac and cheese pizza slice."
3 years ago
Google review
Steve Arnold
"Service was great, food was ok."
3 years ago
Google review
Carlos R.
"Don't get me wrong I love spicy pie and it pains me to write this but it must be done! The fact that I enjoy their pizza buys them an extra star. Out of the last 4 in store visits 3 times they did not have somebody who could man the bar. What??? How do you have a bar in house and be that inconsistent with staffing at the bar (on a football Sunday). I'm sorry..." Read more
3 years ago
Google review
Rick Lemke
"Honestly surprised at how basic this pizza was. Got a pepperoni. The pizza was light on the pepperoni and heavy on the cheese. So much cheese that it was barely melted when it arrived. We ordered it spicy but it wasn't at all. For $22 plus delivery, I expected more for sure."
3 years ago
Google review
Josh Hutchins
"Sandwich was pretty good, service was not. Staff was less than helpful and not very excited to be there."
4 years ago
Google review
Lenny Tweeden
"Not impressed wit the pizza. That's just us. Others I've talked to give it much better reviews."
4 years ago
Google review
Zach DeWald
"Great staff but the pizza is a total let down. Not worth it! What is though is their chicken tacos. Mahi mahi tacos. And the infernal grinder has quite the kick in a good way."
4 years ago
Google review
Bls90
"It’s good pizza if you have never had good pizza the staff was friendly and professional"
4 years ago
Google review
C C
"Edited from 5 star"
4 years ago
Google review
Hope Branch
"Order the pizza of the month which was tge blt pizza, also ordered wings and salads. The portions and size are hug, unfortunately there was no flavor at all with the wings and pizza. Actually had to put our own seasoning on the pizza to be able to eat it. Might try it again but order a different pizza."
4 years ago
Google review
Lucy Casey
"The guy taking my order kept rushing me and rolling his eyes at me. It almost felt like I was the one serving him rather than the other way around .Respect the people you're making your money off of. The only reason this isn't a 1 star review is because the pizza was good."
4 years ago
Google review
Steven Roman
"Good dining experience"
4 years ago
Google review
Carly
"I’ve had several online orders from this location without issue. Today, however, our pizza was totally inaccurate. I ordered a skinny vinny with a few additional toppings on one half. I had to clarify with the employee when I got there at the time it was to be done what the order entailed. ENTIRE pizza is skinny vinny, with half of it with two extra toppings..." Read more
4 years ago
Google review
"We ordered a slice of bbq chicken, carnivore, and sausage. The carnivore and sausage honestly tasted like those little square tostinos pizzas from Walmart. Low quality meats and tasted like cardboard. The BBq chicken was good, but it seemed like all were pretty baked, topped, and then rebuked. Staff was ok but not the most inviting. We would not go back..." Read more
6 months ago