Spicy Pie Reviews & Testimonials

3.9 (1,193)

Reviews: 1,193


5
53%
4
19%
3
8%
2
7%
1
14%

72% of customers would recommend Spicy Pie

  Showing 1 star reviews only  

Ryan Brunelle

Ryan Brunelle star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Ordered a pizza for delivery, quoted 45 minutes. Hour and a half goes by, no delivery. Call and ask about it, they say and I quote "oh we forgot about it, it'll be there in an hour." Hire an adult to run your business, stoned high school kids don't seem to be cutting it."

2 years ago

Google review

Kayley Klinkel

Kayley Klinkel star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"If I could leave 0 stars I would. We pulled up to go here at 8:30, with their open sign still on and people inside sitting on their phones. When I walked up to open the door, it was locked so we called to see if they were open. They said they had closed early due to weather, but the open sign, tvs, and lights were all still on with people inside. Very frustr..." Read more

2 years ago

Google review

Travis Kaneski

Travis Kaneski star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Poor atmosphere"

2 years ago

Google review

Kelsey Rusch

Kelsey Rusch star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"I love their pizza but I work a service job so most of my money comes from tips. They will not allow you to order carry-out unless you pay over the phone on your card. Ridiculous."

2 years ago

Google review

AMARO

AMARO star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"This could be the worst pizza in town. They pre-prepare all of their pizzas. This means crust is made and sauce is put on and then stored on racks sitting there for hours. The pizza is not cooked all the way and you better eat it right there on the spot or else you'll get a cold stale pizza at home. If they made fresh pizza to order they could easily go from..." Read more

2 years ago

Google review

Customer

Customer star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"I went Thursday and got chicken wings & pizza. I'd never ate there before. We had to go to the bar to get drinks and order food. They didnt come to us. The chicken wings were cold. They were cooked, but not warm at all and very soggy. When they brought the food to the table they were very rude just tossed it and rolled their eyes when I asked if I could have..." Read more

2 years ago

Google review

Donna Nelson

Donna Nelson star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"We ordered three pizzas, one being gluten free to go. We got the gluten free relatively fast even though they said it would take 25 minutes. We sat and waited for the other two for an hour and they were only pepperoni pizzas. Finally went up and asked and they have been sitting on their back counter. They had no explanation and did not offer a discount and d..." Read more

2 years ago

Google review

C N

C N star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"I've tried eating Spicy pie pizza twice. There's so much vital gluten in the dough that I'm sick for days afterwards. First time.. thought I had the flu. Second time.. nope.. it's the pizza."

2 years ago

Google review

Tyler Dalk

Tyler Dalk star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Man, the toppings are so bad. So cheap. So flavorless."

2 years ago

Google review

Jeff Baumann

Jeff Baumann star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Apparently they are closed at 1pm on a Monday?"

2 years ago

Google review

Daniel Larios

Daniel Larios star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Over 20 mins for 2 slices of mediocre pizza"

2 years ago

Google review

Daryl

Daryl star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"I have tried to he a Thursday regular. Owning a small business I like to support other local Businesses. In truth I rarely am made to feel I am a regular or that my business matters. Perhaps instead of being on phones, waking away in mid conversation, your Thursday night bartender needs to pay attention to the bar. I get tired of giving your business mon..." Read more

2 years ago

Google review

Ayuub Ibn Jeffrey

Ayuub Ibn Jeffrey star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"This pizza is terrible, I mean I was served better pizza whilst in the public school system."

2 years ago

Google review

Nich Glatt

Nich Glatt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Lack of employees. Didn’t get correct order."

2 years ago

Google review

AN

AN star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Do people still think this is the best pizza in town? Tastes reheated. Jokes on you!"

2 years ago

Google review

Erin A

Erin A star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"I wish we didn’t order from here. They forgot our wings. No apology. Simply wait or leave without them. 25 mins later when the rest of our order was old, we had wings. Extremely disappointed. Very poor customer service."

3 years ago

Google review

Grant Zirtzman

Grant Zirtzman star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"If frozen pizza is an option, I would go that route. Just saying…"

3 years ago

Google review

Tyson Lerfald

Tyson Lerfald star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"What a train wreck! I understand that there is a shortage of employees. The food was awful and I have been a big fan prior. The employees were all sitting around and didn’t know how to make a cheese tostada or a soft shell taco! When it finally came out, was the worst I have had"

3 years ago

Google review

Lucy Staples

Lucy Staples star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Overall bad atmosphere, rude staff, and greasy pizza. And someone was rude to my emo friend, I believe that’s discrimination. $50 down the drain for a bad meal"

3 years ago

Google review

Darren Weisbeck

Darren Weisbeck star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Ordered take out taco pie and 1 beef taco. Upon pickup I payed and was told 3-5 minutes. 15 minutes later I asked about my order. Pie was in warmer for 15 minutes as I waited. Taco was taco meat, cheese thrown in microwave. Pizza was not hot and very little toppings. Eaten here twice, do not recommend."

3 years ago

Google review

Mott

Mott star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"SO DRY!! Dryer than the Sahara desert. Where that sauce at? Each slice had about 1 milliliter of sauce!!"

3 years ago

Google review

Kaleb Blotske

Kaleb Blotske star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Never written a review before but the pizza was so bad I had too. Not even half cooked"

3 years ago

Google review

Lance Porter

Lance Porter star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"By not accepting cash anymore, you’re also not accepting my business. Genius move."

3 years ago

Google review

Robert Buda

Robert Buda star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"The pizza was horrible and all the ingredients were not cooked. Any frozen pizza from the grocery store is better than this"

3 years ago

Google review

T K

T K star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Worst pizza I've ever had. Went in, first time ordering here, saw old pizza on racks and commented to my family "look at the old gross pizza" thinking maybe they were for display. Cold congealed cheese, dry, guess what pizza I got..? They are reheated pizzas. They prep them, leave them out, then add toppings and reheat when you order it. The crust was crunch..." Read more

3 years ago

Google review