TripAdvisor 
Google 
Dan M
KB Marie
"Ordered delivery to our hotel room. Called over an hour before closing time to place the order. The food never showed up, and nobody called me back. We are extremely disappointed."
8 years ago
Google review
Aaron Schwartz
"Food was brought burnt. People who work here are unfriendly tools. Single slice took over 45 min. Don't waste your time or money."
8 years ago
Google review
Brenda Hansen
"Waited over an hour and a half for my delivery order. This just pissed me off."
9 years ago
Google review
Iv Strand
"I like Spicy Pie, don't get me wrong, but for this location I can only give one star for the food. The last couple times I have done a web order to pick up, something was forgotten, which is ridiculous. Once, the peppers were forgotten on my nachos. Fine, I can forgive one mistake. This time I was given a gift card for Christmas, made an online order with..." Read more
9 years ago
Google review
Isaac Schwartz
"I paid $25 for one large pizza and it was bad. Too much cheese, the crust was mushy and tasteless, the toppings were scant. I would strongly urge you to go to Rhombus Guys instead. Domino's or Papa John's would be a vast improvement also."
9 years ago
Google review
Damon Larson
"Slow service. Tried it the day it opened and two or three times since. Never changes. Very poor. Food is average... no complaints."
10 years ago
Google review
Ryan Ottis
"Pathetically slow, wish I could say better about this place"
11 years ago
Google review
Janessa Peterson
"Save yourself the trouble, STAY AWAY. I have given Spicy Pie several chances to change my opinion, but they never fail to disappoint. The service, if you can call it that, is a JOKE. Either the servers have no desire to be there or they only function on one speed...SLOW motion. The food takes forever. We placed our order at the same time we ordered our dri..." Read more
11 years ago
Google review
Trent Laugerman
"Horrible service. Had to wait over 30 minutes for 2 slices with maybe 6 patrons in the restaurant. Understaffed."
11 years ago
Google review
Brice Nelson
"Only leaving one star because I can't rate it at zero stars!!! This place is HORRIBLE!!! Don't waste your money here. We ordered our food and the service started out fine, but quickly changed. The staff was fine, it is the management. Half way through our grinder, we bite into a twist tie from the bread package. Who knows where this has been. Pretty c..." Read more
11 years ago
Google review
Jesse Clark
"Waited over an hour for 18" while dining in. Sloppy service for average food. Cool tables."
13 years ago
Google review
"Dining in a couple years ago was okay, but not the case regarding delivery. Took under 2 hours from placing my order online to receiving my one pizza and I live 3 miles away. Was given no courtesy call saying that my pizza was on its way and had to call twice to figure out where it was and I was just told it was on its way. Pizza was barely warm when I go..." Read more
8 years ago