TripAdvisor 
Google 
John Eaton
Marvin Calice
"The pizza is the closest to New York style you can find around here. Years ago, I loved this place and got pies here all the time. But why pay double for something similar."
7 months ago
Google review
Chris Knopik
"Always has been great pizza. This time we got ours to go. Who ever made the pizza's didn't put any sauce on both of our pizza's. We live 80 miles from the nearest Spicy Pie. It was to late to take it back. We will give it one more chance."
8 months ago
Google review
Indigo Hopkins
"Terribly slow service"
8 months ago
Google review
Heather Griffith
"Called in an order while in town visiting and arrived one minute after it was done. Staff were busy talking to each other in the kitchen, even looked up at me, but didn’t say anything. By time I got my pizza it was cold. It was an average pie. Looks like a fun spot to hang out at though! Arcade games for kids and gambling spots for adults"
9 months ago
Google review
Hutch
"Phenomenal pizza. One bite everyone knows the rules. Great undercarriage. Perfect spice."
9 months ago
Google review
Daniel Nicolas
"Rant: Ordered BBQ chicken Pie and a bbq grindr (at Spicy Pie) they gave me a Buffalo pizza . I called once I got home at 8:36pm that I just wanted it to be replaced with correct pizza and I’ll bring back the wrong pizza. I brought right back. For some reason the lady was giving a cash refund. She told the guy not to make it. Then i told her I just wanted the..." Read more
10 months ago
Google review
Everett Higginbotham
"Papa Murphy with a sports bar attached. Same store bought crust with Chuck E. Cheese Toppings. My son warned me it wasn’t going to be good. Bar pizza in turtle lake is better quality and flavor."
10 months ago
Google review
Lori Schutt
"Great pizza! Service was okay. Just not overly friendly. No smiles. No chit chat. I really enjoyed my taco salad and my other peeps ordered a slice each. They also enjoyed their food."
a year ago
Google review
Daniel McCollum
"Hadn't been to the Spicy Pie in about a decade (somehow, whenever I was back in town visiting friends, we never swung down). So THIS year I made an extra effort and stopped in the first thing I did. Totally worth it! Brought back memories as I chowed down on my old standard: two slices of pepperoni and sausage, one with the spicy marinara. Ahhhhhhhh, co..." Read more
a year ago
Google review
Brennan 420
"I visited Spicy Pie on 04-Jan-2025. I was recommended to go there by a friendly U.S. Border Agent. Unfortunately, the pizza was underwhelming. The crust was doughy and very thin. I had the carnivore and mac n cheese slices. Neither of them were good, and my wife was not impressed by her pepperoni slices. I will not return"
a year ago
Google review
Dylan L
"You’re paying for the vibes not the food."
a year ago
Google review
Kayla Boulduc
"Went there with a group of nine people in age ranging from 62 to 21 they denied the whole table drinks because they’re new RUDE bartender scanned an id wrong of a 24 year old"
a year ago
Google review
Bryan Trosen
"Best grinders in Fargo! And that red head that works there is such a sweetie 😊 (Being her dad, I might be a little biased 😛)"
a year ago
Google review
kristine
"If I could give it zero star I would .....was the worst place for food I have been in ages . Got 2 tostada's I couldn't even take a hole bite due to fact it was SATURATED in greese 🤢also got the nachos which were also to greasy ..not as bad as the toastadas but still bad enough so a waste of 17 bucks for food I couldn't eat"
a year ago
Google review
B
"Pizza has no flavor even with toppings, taste like thin cardboard. Got two slices and only could choke down half of one. It would help if they put some sauce on it.."
a year ago
Google review
Scott S.
"Good place to get pizza. Lady at the front took time to tell us about the different types. Thank you Victoria for great service."
a year ago
Google review
Adriene Daniel
"Son has been working for them for years. Glad we had some tasty 'Za"
a year ago
Google review
iMbue (iMbue)
"D- pizza might as well be raw. Wrong crust type. Basically an insult to pizza. Saw in an ad NY style pizza and that comparison is offensive. I could have cooked it better in an easy-bake oven with the light bulb barely working. Atmosphere was ok and pizza was on time (likely because of all the time they saved not cooking it)"
a year ago
Google review
Ivy Barrels
"Pizza was just ok. I guess I've had worse. Too greasy and the bacon was too salty. Slow service, too"
a year ago
Google review
Tim Behrens- Lefty guitar
"Greasy pile of glop."
a year ago
Google review
Joel H
"Fantástico"
a year ago
Google review
shnakyy
"The pizza was absolutely disgusting. It tasted more artificial than any pizza I’ve had in my life. It was greasy, but not a good type of grease, and the cheese had a sharpness to it like was it white cheddar. It was $5 for one slice, and the slice was cold."
a year ago
Google review
Shannon Burton
"Excellent service , food and atmosphere!"
a year ago
Google review
Derrick M70
"By all accounts it should be a cool place with great pizza. All attempts at trendy point that way but the pizza is barely bar worthy. Somehow the crust is burnt and not done at the same time. Floppy sloppy greasy cardboard made too big and hard to eat. I guess locals like it but if you're in from out of town don't bother. There's gotta be better. I get th..." Read more
a year ago
Google review
"Tried contacting through you site… I went to the fair today the magiccon and I was looking forward to getting some pizza with my little girl. You had one slice of cheese left for her and I asked if another one’s coming out and I was told they’re not gonna put any more out until the other others Have been sold. I would’ve gotten two additional slices that yo..." Read more
7 months ago