TripAdvisor 
Google 
Kayley Klinkel
Travis Kaneski
"Poor atmosphere"
2 years ago
Google review
Adrienne Olson
"Great place for kids' lunch in downtown Fargo! We were thrilled to find mac and cheese on the menu. Next door to Fargo Theatre on Broadway. Great value if you are tired of buying restaurant kid meals that end up half eaten and too expensive. HUGE slices of pizza by the way!"
2 years ago
Google review
Hazel Naanes
"I never had a problem waiting for my food here until recently. I ordered a single slice of pizza that ended up taking an hour. Staff were nice enough, but it still doesn't excuse the absurd amount of time. Disappointed and won't be returning for awhile."
2 years ago
Google review
Jeff Ehlers
"Disappointed that they no longer have soda or water fountain."
2 years ago
Google review
Ben Buchmiller
"My wife went here and got the bacon Mac and cheese pizza slice."
2 years ago
Google review
Jake Bodensteiner
"Great spot for a beer and some pizza 🍕"
2 years ago
Google review
Eric Locken
"Great service and new york style slices."
2 years ago
Google review
Steve Arnold
"Service was great, food was ok."
2 years ago
Google review
Kelsey Rusch
"I love their pizza but I work a service job so most of my money comes from tips. They will not allow you to order carry-out unless you pay over the phone on your card. Ridiculous."
2 years ago
Google review
Guido N
"Sorry, tried it twice. Horrible crust, and each time under baked."
2 years ago
Google review
CCOD
"Was visiting from out of state, and it was close to the hotel. Went over it was blown away by how good the food was."
2 years ago
Google review
AMARO
"This could be the worst pizza in town. They pre-prepare all of their pizzas. This means crust is made and sauce is put on and then stored on racks sitting there for hours. The pizza is not cooked all the way and you better eat it right there on the spot or else you'll get a cold stale pizza at home. If they made fresh pizza to order they could easily go from..." Read more
2 years ago
Google review
Cyndi Schefflin
"Hubby and I are on a road trip from Idaho to Minnesota and now back to Idaho. We stopped in Fargo for our first overnight and my darling found this pizza place knowing how much I love a good pizza. Unless you are with a few people or ultra hungry go the slice route. Slice is large and delicious!! Beer or soda with your meal. Great employees, excellent piz..." Read more
2 years ago
Google review
Customer
"I went Thursday and got chicken wings & pizza. I'd never ate there before. We had to go to the bar to get drinks and order food. They didnt come to us. The chicken wings were cold. They were cooked, but not warm at all and very soggy. When they brought the food to the table they were very rude just tossed it and rolled their eyes when I asked if I could have..." Read more
2 years ago
Google review
Joseph Casey
"Good pizza, not too big of a fan of their cheese"
2 years ago
Google review
Donna Nelson
"We ordered three pizzas, one being gluten free to go. We got the gluten free relatively fast even though they said it would take 25 minutes. We sat and waited for the other two for an hour and they were only pepperoni pizzas. Finally went up and asked and they have been sitting on their back counter. They had no explanation and did not offer a discount and d..." Read more
2 years ago
Google review
Carlos R.
"Don't get me wrong I love spicy pie and it pains me to write this but it must be done! The fact that I enjoy their pizza buys them an extra star. Out of the last 4 in store visits 3 times they did not have somebody who could man the bar. What??? How do you have a bar in house and be that inconsistent with staffing at the bar (on a football Sunday). I'm sorry..." Read more
2 years ago
Google review
C N
"I've tried eating Spicy pie pizza twice. There's so much vital gluten in the dough that I'm sick for days afterwards. First time.. thought I had the flu. Second time.. nope.. it's the pizza."
2 years ago
Google review
Brandon Hjermstad
"Great food. Quick service. The booths are pretty uncomfortable but it goes with the atmosphere. It's a nice place. Very clean a d lively. They had live music while I was there. It was outside and there were no spectators. I felt bad because the music was great, it was just cold."
2 years ago
Google review
Tyler Dalk
"Man, the toppings are so bad. So cheap. So flavorless."
2 years ago
Google review
John Doe
"I ate here with my girlfriend right before we moved out of state, the pizza here is delicious. The toppings tasted fresh and savory. I definitely recommend the ranch chicken pizza and the cinnamon sugar desserts."
2 years ago
Google review
Jeff Baumann
"Apparently they are closed at 1pm on a Monday?"
2 years ago
Google review
Talitha Mathre
"Was awesome"
2 years ago
Google review
Tom Ambrosio
"I'm a transplant from New Jersey and couldn't find good pizza in Fargo for over a decade until spicy pie came to town.Excellent pizza and their pizza the month is always innovative!!"
2 years ago
Google review
"If I could leave 0 stars I would. We pulled up to go here at 8:30, with their open sign still on and people inside sitting on their phones. When I walked up to open the door, it was locked so we called to see if they were open. They said they had closed early due to weather, but the open sign, tvs, and lights were all still on with people inside. Very frustr..." Read more
2 years ago