TripAdvisor 
Google 
Richard Gleason
Ryan Ottis
"Pathetically slow, wish I could say better about this place"
11 years ago
Google review
Janessa Peterson
"Save yourself the trouble, STAY AWAY. I have given Spicy Pie several chances to change my opinion, but they never fail to disappoint. The service, if you can call it that, is a JOKE. Either the servers have no desire to be there or they only function on one speed...SLOW motion. The food takes forever. We placed our order at the same time we ordered our dri..." Read more
11 years ago
Google review
Mira Paulson
"yuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuum!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
11 years ago
Google review
michael bohn
"Red dough ?"
11 years ago
Google review
Paul Leintz
"So so pizza. Not really going to go out of my way to eat there."
11 years ago
Google review
Trent Laugerman
"Horrible service. Had to wait over 30 minutes for 2 slices with maybe 6 patrons in the restaurant. Understaffed."
11 years ago
Google review
Andrew B (darth taters)
"I want to love Spicy Pie. I honestly do. They have the hip/urban decor, the NY-style pizza, the fantastic downtown location...but the pizza is just bad. I've tried time and time again to turn my opinion around on this place, but every time I stop in I regret it. The crust is consistently burnt black and the cheese and sauce are practically nonexistent, leav..." Read more
11 years ago
Google review
Brice Nelson
"Only leaving one star because I can't rate it at zero stars!!! This place is HORRIBLE!!! Don't waste your money here. We ordered our food and the service started out fine, but quickly changed. The staff was fine, it is the management. Half way through our grinder, we bite into a twist tie from the bread package. Who knows where this has been. Pretty c..." Read more
11 years ago
Google review
Vanessa Manor
"To expensive for what it is"
11 years ago
Google review
Rachel Knight
"Horrible service and even more horrible food"
12 years ago
Google review
Jon Kilimnik
"I was down from winnipeg for one night and found Spicy Pie on recommendation from Tim at Dempsey's. I was impressed with this place. Now York slice in North Dakota! No complaints. It was very close to the real thing and not expensive. The staff were cheerful and friendly."
12 years ago
Google review
Matt Turner
"People were nice there and it was cool to see the crust being hand made right next to the ordering counter. We ordered on one half of the pizza just cheese and pepperoni and the other half with cheese, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, and jalapenos. The kids enjoyed the pepperoni side but my wife and I loved the other side. The toppings were fresh and the p..." Read more
12 years ago
Google review
Beau Lundmark
"The sauce tasted like ketchup and tomatoe paste. That was the most flavorful part of the pizza."
13 years ago
Google review
Kalene Sharstrom
"I enjoy going to Spicy Pie on occasion. We usually have a good experience with food quality, and when we did have a bad slice, it was immediately corrected. But the service is rather on the sluggish side, especially during busy times. It is a small sized restaurant (just a bit larger than JL Beers) so if you are coming in with a big group, plan ahead to grab..." Read more
13 years ago
Google review
Jesse Clark
"Waited over an hour for 18" while dining in. Sloppy service for average food. Cool tables."
13 years ago
Google review
"Love it! Be sure to take home the sauce, highly recommend it on egg-breakfast dishes!"
10 years ago