Spicy Pie Reviews & Testimonials

3.9 (1,191)

Reviews: 1,191


5
53%
4
19%
3
8%
2
7%
1
13%

72% of customers would recommend Spicy Pie

Darlene Gryskiewicz

Darlene Gryskiewicz star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Great tasting pizza!"

6 years ago

Google review

Big Daddy (BigDaddyvwxyz)

Big Daddy (BigDaddyvwxyz) star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Lame pizza"

6 years ago

Google review

D.G. Dempsey

D.G. Dempsey star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Good food. Need one in Williston"

6 years ago

Google review

Keira Scoles

Keira Scoles star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"They were very kind, the pizza was delicious, and it was nicely decorated"

6 years ago

Google review

Dan

Dan star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"They have a really fun outdoor area."

6 years ago

Google review

Terry B

Terry B star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Great pizza, service or staff is friendly if your under 25"

6 years ago

Google review

Wandering Waylander

Wandering Waylander star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Delicious large slices and local brews on tap for a decent price. Some of the Best happy hour pricing downtown."

6 years ago

Google review

John Smith Jr.

John Smith Jr. star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

""It's a 5 when you're hungry and a 2 when you're not," said Annalise."

6 years ago

Google review

kirby “Stomp” plante

kirby “Stomp” plante star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Beef & bfast bacon"

6 years ago

Google review

Emily

Emily star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"NOT WHAT I ORDERED. Every single time I have ever ordered from the West Fargo location my order has been incorrect. My order is typically missing slices of pizza, but I have also received burnt grinders. I’ve been here a number of times hoping it gets better but it never has."

6 years ago

Google review

Dray Morgan

Dray Morgan star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"My first time to spicy pie and I was not disappointed in the least"

6 years ago

Google review

Joylyn Gray

Joylyn Gray star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"If you are in Fargo you have to try this pizza. It's perfection! Great toppings baked in a wood fired oven! And the staff are very sweet"

6 years ago

Google review

Brad Hutch

Brad Hutch star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"New york style pizza HUGE SLICES!"

6 years ago

Google review

Ron Dautel

Ron Dautel star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"I grab a slice every so often when I'm downtown. It's decent priced and fills you up. Pretty good pizza."

6 years ago

Google review

Michael Brown

Michael Brown star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Just okay not great not terrible."

6 years ago

Google review

Michal Pruett

Michal Pruett star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Ordered a pizza, waited the hour for delivery, they delivered my pizza to someone else and brought their pizza to me. He called their store. No offer of refund, no offer to make the correct one, just "you can keep this one" so I had him take it back so they could make the correct one. I called to see how long it was going to be, the lady on the phone was qui..." Read more

6 years ago

Google review

60 Gunner

60 Gunner star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"I'm from out of town. I enjoyed the atmosphere and the pizza was great. My son loves New York style pizza he loved it."

6 years ago

Google review

Galvin Standish

Galvin Standish star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Great pieces of pie."

6 years ago

Google review

A Caldwell

A Caldwell star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"The pizza here is always hot and fresh, and the slices are gigantic. I really like the decor and feel of this place, and it's nice in the summer because the air conditioning is very strong."

6 years ago

Google review

Rod Trudeau

Rod Trudeau star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"The pizza was good but a little skimpy and a little pricey and the tables were dirty"

6 years ago

Google review

Bertram Donley

Bertram Donley star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Real NY pizza by the slice in of all places, Fargo, ND!"

6 years ago

Google review

Amber Pitts

Amber Pitts star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"It was my first time here. The young lady that help was really friendly and helped me order and pizza. And since I didn't know what kind they had. She was smiling the whole time. Amazing fast. Pizza was amazing and tasted amazing!"

6 years ago

Google review

hyperglobalmega

hyperglobalmega star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Excellent pizza. Very eclectic location."

6 years ago

Google review

Steve M

Steve M star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Fantastic people work here and they know how to treat customers right!"

6 years ago

Google review

m haagenstad

m haagenstad star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"One of the best tasting pizzas in town!! The CRUST! Great flavors, just on point. Not the quickest service, I would recommend calling in your order for pick up. If you eat in, check out the juke box while you wait. Of course you can just use their delivery service."

6 years ago

Google review