TripAdvisor 
Google 
Jon Kilimnik
Matt Turner
"People were nice there and it was cool to see the crust being hand made right next to the ordering counter. We ordered on one half of the pizza just cheese and pepperoni and the other half with cheese, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, and jalapenos. The kids enjoyed the pepperoni side but my wife and I loved the other side. The toppings were fresh and the p..." Read more
14 years ago
Google review
Beau Lundmark
"The sauce tasted like ketchup and tomatoe paste. That was the most flavorful part of the pizza."
14 years ago
Google review
Kalene Sharstrom
"I enjoy going to Spicy Pie on occasion. We usually have a good experience with food quality, and when we did have a bad slice, it was immediately corrected. But the service is rather on the sluggish side, especially during busy times. It is a small sized restaurant (just a bit larger than JL Beers) so if you are coming in with a big group, plan ahead to grab..." Read more
14 years ago
Google review
Jesse Clark
"Waited over an hour for 18" while dining in. Sloppy service for average food. Cool tables."
14 years ago
Google review
"I was down from winnipeg for one night and found Spicy Pie on recommendation from Tim at Dempsey's. I was impressed with this place. Now York slice in North Dakota! No complaints. It was very close to the real thing and not expensive. The staff were cheerful and friendly."
13 years ago