Spicy Pie Reviews & Testimonials

3.9 (1,189)

Reviews: 1,189


5
53%
4
19%
3
8%
2
7%
1
13%

72% of customers would recommend Spicy Pie

Alan Tillinghast

Alan Tillinghast star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Great tasting pizza. Wonderful service. Slices where a little large, but they cut them down ."

2 years ago

Google review

Genesis Berry

Genesis Berry star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"This pizza severely lacks flavor and they have slow service"

2 years ago

Google review

Nathaniel Hooper

Nathaniel Hooper star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Great service, friendly smiles. Decent food for the price, good hours for the munchies and their gluten-free pizzas are pretty damn good."

2 years ago

Google review

Jen or Leonard Beck

Jen or Leonard Beck star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Food there is Bussin my son says. I think that mesns AWESOME 😊 Highly recommend. Wonderful place, with good food and service. A local favorite forcsure!"

2 years ago

Google review

Richard Dagostino

Richard Dagostino star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Always found it difficult to find good pizza in the Midwest. This was amongst the better in the area. I did have to add black pepper. Although that was easy enough. I left pleased with my purchase. I found the younger staff to be very efficient, knowledgeable and polite. The atmosphere had a nice feel although somewhat of a small place. I'll be back."

2 years ago

Google review

Moodie Foodie

Moodie Foodie star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"The pizza is absolutely amazing, which is topped off with the most amazing staff! Pizza by the slice, made to order is sublime and their specialty pizzas are great. The Mac n cheese is a must everytime! The grinders remind us of back home on the east coast!"

2 years ago

Google review

Isaiah Smith

Isaiah Smith star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Normally your food was good but whoever made my spicy chz pizza at 11:30 AM, please let them know that it was either too much cheese, or not cooked long enough when I asked it for well done I mean burnt. The cheese had 0 golden color to it. It was all white and gross. I Spent $35 on this so I need it to taste good. Which it usually does. Now I’m down $35 for..." Read more

2 years ago

Google review

Bobbie Sorlien

Bobbie Sorlien star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Needs to work on cleaning up A little..tables were disgusting, bathrooms were as well."

2 years ago

Google review

Francis Froehlich

Francis Froehlich star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Fast pizza type food. it's pretty good for pizza."

2 years ago

Google review

Jessica b

Jessica b star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Awesome"

2 years ago

Google review

Luke Larson

Luke Larson star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Pickles, bacon, and ranch? Yup. It was amazing. Great atmosphere and friendly staff. Garlic knots were in point as well."

2 years ago

Google review

Jake Stclaire

Jake Stclaire star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Not a fan."

2 years ago

Google review

Naomi Marks

Naomi Marks star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"The staff were very friendly and the pizza was ready very quick."

2 years ago

Google review

Beatrice Kinzler

Beatrice Kinzler star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Wonderful food. Usually pick up to take home. Service is great."

2 years ago

Google review

Maegan Spotted Elk

Maegan Spotted Elk star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Went here recently and got two pepperoni pizza slices,it was delicious and the cooks were very inviting. Would definitely return for more pizza 🍕😍"

2 years ago

Google review

Grace Tolson

Grace Tolson star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Like others have stated, pizza wasn't cooked all the way through, very bland. Tastes very artificial. I got a pepperoni and ended up tossing half of it. I tried to remedy it with oregano and red pepper and Parm at home and even that couldn't save it"

2 years ago

Google review

55 555

55 555 star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"The pizza is good but the music they play is too loud. This isn't a nightclub. Turn it down."

2 years ago

Google review

Jonathan Kreil

Jonathan Kreil star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Very good pizza. Very friendly service. The only hang up was a very rude and obnoxious customer. The employees ended up kicking him out."

2 years ago

Google review

Michael Cavo

Michael Cavo star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"No flavor"

2 years ago

Google review

Jason Karlson

Jason Karlson star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Food is amazing"

2 years ago

Google review

Kate Bunkelman

Kate Bunkelman star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Best pizza in town Good atmosphere Bar area E slots"

2 years ago

Google review

Lyn Szuch

Lyn Szuch star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"It has some fun pizza and unique atmosphere. Not really a kid friendly location... Gambling, lots of alcohol, inappropriate words and pictures on tables and walls. But the pickle bacon ranch pizza is pretty good."

2 years ago

Google review

Ryan Brunelle

Ryan Brunelle star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Ordered a pizza for delivery, quoted 45 minutes. Hour and a half goes by, no delivery. Call and ask about it, they say and I quote "oh we forgot about it, it'll be there in an hour." Hire an adult to run your business, stoned high school kids don't seem to be cutting it."

2 years ago

Google review

Kory Hochsprung

Kory Hochsprung star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Tried the salami grinder, lots of bread lots of lettuce not much meat. And was kinda expensive."

2 years ago

Google review

Ted Hoselton

Ted Hoselton star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt star-alt

"Wouldn’t accept cash for delivery. The total was less then $22"

2 years ago

Google review