TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,231 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
Lenny Tweeden
Mott
"SO DRY!! Dryer than the Sahara desert. Where that sauce at? Each slice had about 1 milliliter of sauce!!"
5 years ago
Google review
Dan Quaas
"Can't go wrong at Spicy Pie. Always a favorite when visiting our boys in college."
5 years ago
Google review
Jeff Doerr
"Loved it! Great lunch choice, staff extremely friendly and polite. Value based and quality driven! Thank you Spicy Pie."
5 years ago
Google review
Malachi Askeland
"Very good food."
5 years ago
Google review
Zach DeWald
"Great staff but the pizza is a total let down. Not worth it! What is though is their chicken tacos. Mahi mahi tacos. And the infernal grinder has quite the kick in a good way."
5 years ago
Google review
Kaleb Blotske
"Never written a review before but the pizza was so bad I had too. Not even half cooked"
5 years ago
Google review
Kristi Stelzner
"There food is good and it never take long"
5 years ago
Google review
Miquela Scott
"Great food!"
5 years ago
Google review
Anton Ward
"Great restaurant with amazing employees. I also ordered a single slice to try the food and it was great as well. All around great experience would highly recommend."
5 years ago
Google review
Hana M
"The food here are surprisingly good. Affordable price , good location and friendly staff. I ordered the one with all the meats on it, love it. If we visit Fargo again, we will be back."
5 years ago
Google review
Maren Wakefield
"Tasty pizza and you can still get a pitcher of beer with it!"
5 years ago
Google review
Reese Schneider
"Kinda unsorted really greasy for the pepperoni"
5 years ago
Google review
Bls90
"It’s good pizza if you have never had good pizza the staff was friendly and professional"
5 years ago
Google review
Will Larson
"Great tasting slice - some flop, good ratio of sauce, plenty of cheese. Good crust. Score of an 8.3 - and that’s my review"
5 years ago
Google review
Jayson Pasch
"Nice place; pizza was ready fast. The pizza had little no flavor as far as the cheese, pretty much no sauce, cheese was under cooked. Not sure if I'll go back."
5 years ago
Google review
Rob
"Brought my niece who was up from Florida. She loved her slice! I had the special of the month (Nov 2021) was amazing. Great service and great comfort food."
5 years ago
Google review
Brandon Nelson
"Simply the best in ND! Great Pizza!"
5 years ago
Google review
nelsh vowin
"Good college pizza. Crust was crispy."
5 years ago
Google review
B Ray
"Great pizza!! Cool place!"
5 years ago
Google review
Maggie Morrison (MggieSenpai)
"Delicious! I love coming here, love by the slice pizza places. Their selection is amazing. Sometimes a little slow, but well worth the wait!"
5 years ago
Google review
Lance Porter
"By not accepting cash anymore, you’re also not accepting my business. Genius move."
5 years ago
Google review
Robert Buda
"The pizza was horrible and all the ingredients were not cooked. Any frozen pizza from the grocery store is better than this"
5 years ago
Google review
Damian Vincent
"Great"
5 years ago
Google review
Cameron Brown
"Fun atmosphere, quick service."
5 years ago
Google review
"Not impressed wit the pizza. That's just us. Others I've talked to give it much better reviews."
5 years ago