TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,231 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
tina heimsness
Thalia Wood
"Great pizza! Love that you can just get a slice. And the spicy sauce is fantastic š"
5 years ago
Google review
Carly
"Iāve had several online orders from this location without issue. Today, however, our pizza was totally inaccurate. I ordered a skinny vinny with a few additional toppings on one half. I had to clarify with the employee when I got there at the time it was to be done what the order entailed. ENTIRE pizza is skinny vinny, with half of it with two extra toppings..." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
Scott Christensen
"Neat little pizza shop. Can get by the slice or a full pie. Great staff quick. No complaints"
5 years ago
Google review
Melissa Baya
"Hello all! I feel the need to share about my horrid experience with the N. Broadway Spicy Pie, and the shift supervisor, Danielle. I order delivery from this Spicy Pie 2-4 times wkly, every week (I like my food š¤·š¤£) However, tonight I was refused delivery by Danielle - who said they cannot deliver to me anymore bc of complaints. WHAT??? The only complain..." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
Joshua Hagen
"Ordered several times and absolutely love the huge slices"
5 years ago
Google review
Kevin
"Good pizza and tacos, but spendy"
5 years ago
Google review
Mike Dunn
"Definitely the worst pizza I've had in Minot. Customer service is about as bad as I've experienced also. Undercover boss needed for this place."
5 years ago
Google review
Michael Scott
"I'm from the new york-philly metro area and the pizza was not ny style at all and the philly cheese steak not like the ones in Philly. Nonetheless it was a cool atmosphere and they make a decent pie"
5 years ago
Google review
Nate Ray
"Slow service and my order has never not gotten lost."
5 years ago
Google review
Mariam Almozrouei
"My husband ordered a pizza without bacon, and they put bacon, when we called about it they said āsometimes we donāt have the best people working hereā š."
5 years ago
Google review
Shaun Flick
"Good pizza. Great flavors"
5 years ago
Google review
Alicia Waters
"If you are looking for a New York slice this is not it, I keep trying to give this place the benefit of the doubt, but if you have a craving for a great slice that you used to be able to get on any street THIS IS NOT IT! It might be the best the Midwest can offer, but this is not what you are craving :("
5 years ago
Google review
Tim W
"Pizza was great as always! Tried the zeppolis which tasted awesome!"
5 years ago
Google review
Robert D.
"Not a single issue with Spicy pie in the 2 years I've lived here, Pizza is always good, albeit sometimes overloaded (especially the mac and cheese) so be prepared to two hand, fold or even (I know this is heresy) use a fork and knife. Best thing I love about Spicy Pie though is that a lot of pizza places are going for the 14" as their standard, heck a few o..." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
Hans Luft
"About a good as it gets for pizza in the Fargo area. Their selection is unrivaled in terms of flavors and toppings."
5 years ago
Google review
Phil Wik
"Super good pizza!! We always look for good local NY style pizza while on vacation. Spicy Pie was absolutely amazing!"
5 years ago
Google review
Cindy Mccauley
"The staff is very friendly the pizza is awesome.I would recommend all should visit there."
5 years ago
Google review
Mike Nelson
"The best pizza in Fargo...no cap."
5 years ago
Google review
Chelsi Jasmijn
"IT WAS AMAZING!!! The restaurant was so unique and different from anywhere i've ever been! Our server, Lincoln, was an angel sent from heaven. He was so nice and he recommended the Pizza of the Month (Mango Tango), and it was probably the best pizza I've ever had (it's a bit spicy, so be careful)! This establishment had great customer service, prices, AND F..." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
Daniel Bauder
"Favorite hang out for drinks and pizza."
5 years ago
Google review
Alex Tangen
"We got great service, and amazing food!I totally reccomend!!!"
5 years ago
Google review
Hunter Bolte
"Spicy Pie is always a safe bet when it comes to places to eat. The thin, hot and delicious pizza is always a treat. The staff at this location were nice and made it relatively quickly as well. The location is also superb, and I can imagine it's nice living in the connected apartments."
5 years ago
Google review
Kelly Gallegos
"Pizza wasn't too bad, place looked fun with all of the visual items but customer service was lacking! I stood at the counter for a long time and no one greeted me until asked where do we order. There were alot of employees behind the counter making the food and no one acknowledged me. After I paid I said thank you and the lady didnt say thank you back. W..." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
Kelsey Murberger
"Great pizza if you can get it hot. Staff seems a little disorganized"
5 years ago
Google review
"Pizza is delicious Love it"
5 years ago