TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,173 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
Aaron Waite
Scott Walters
"Go somewhere else for your pizza by the slice. The service was a bit slow and inaccurate. I ordered one kind of beer and they brought a different one. The food is nothing special. Not bad, but you can definitely find better."
8 years ago
Google review
Steve Doroff
"Great pizza. Great prices. Never leave hungry."
8 years ago
Google review
KB Marie
"Ordered delivery to our hotel room. Called over an hour before closing time to place the order. The food never showed up, and nobody called me back. We are extremely disappointed."
8 years ago
Google review
Cady Jarman
"I. Love. Spicy. Pie. Their pizzas are so amazing, I crave them just about every other day. Of course I can't let myself have it ever other day because their slices are huge! Pretty much double the size of what a regular slice would be, and the price isn't bad...for a slice. It does start getting pricy when you want an entire pizza, but I can't say I'd compla..." Read more
8 years ago
Google review
John Beach
"Drastic turn around in both quality and customer service! Bread bites are the best thing I the menu!"
8 years ago
Google review
Dale Murphy
"Friendly staff, good food, and cool tables."
8 years ago
Google review
Chase Cole
"Good food and afordable prices."
8 years ago
Google review
Justin Tuchek
"I like this location the best out of all of them in Fargo - outdoor fireplace is the best!"
8 years ago
Google review
C Strand
"Pizza is similar to what you would find in New York. One of our favorite places to go. Try the ultimate grinder."
8 years ago
Google review
David Scott
"Pizza is good. Great atmosphere, the outside fire pit is super cool."
8 years ago
Google review
Aaron Schwartz
"Food was brought burnt. People who work here are unfriendly tools. Single slice took over 45 min. Don't waste your time or money."
8 years ago
Google review
Alex Gackle
"Staff suck. The pizza is good though."
8 years ago
Google review
nikodemous hadera
"Stopped in on a Friday night and had an incredible experience. It honestly seemed like the employees enjoyed preforming their job. Most notably rick, joe, and atlee made it a plesant expirenece. 4 stars for the pizza, you get what you pay for their but what really made me give them 5 stars was their staff."
8 years ago
Google review
Brian Bjugstad
"I did not like their pizza. It could be good but the whole par baking then adding topping on top turned me off. Admittedly I have not been here in a couple years. The grinder was ok though."
8 years ago
Google review
Matt Byrd
"I stopped in late on night about 20 mons before close and the employees were more than hospitable even though it was so close to closeing time. They took the time to explain the specials and even saved me money though their nightly happy hour. If rick or lane are working you are in more than capable hands. Would strongly recommend to anyone"
8 years ago
Google review
Kevin Doran
"Great pizza at a good price. Friendly staff."
8 years ago
Google review
Dylan Hildenbrand
"Sign up for the rewards program. Get a free pizza with a purchase of a pitcher of beer every night from 7 to 11. Worth it. As far as service and the food goes, I've had mixed results. I've been here when the server has forgotten to put in our order, and another time when the cooks just forgot to make our pizza. It's frustrating, but it happens. Most of the..." Read more
8 years ago
Google review
Ben W Gunter
"A little high priced and I expected more, like sauce and toppings to the outside. Very little sauce and toppings bunched in the middle..what a waste"
8 years ago
Google review
Jeff Feller
"I'm a big fan of Spicy Pie. I've eaten at every one of their locations thus far as well. Good food. Since I live in Minot, I've been to this location the most... The staff has really been stellar lately!"
8 years ago
Google review
Jacob Mischel
"This is the second week in a row that my order has been forgotten after 40mins over lunch. It wasn't terribly busy, but I still had to bother the cashier as to where the order was. After she dug through a stack of reciepts, I finally got my food. All in all, the food is great. The service at this location in particular is terrible."
8 years ago
Google review
Jazmin Luna
"Our favorite pizza place !"
8 years ago
Google review
Conveyer Conveyer
"Luke, Rick and Lexi took care of us, even comp'd a few pies that never got picked up. This is a must stop for us whenever we are in Fargo. They will have our business for years to come."
8 years ago
Google review
Jared Evangelista
"Luke, Rick, and Lexie were super awesome. I live all the way out in Michigan and was just passing through. They were nice enough to let us stay a little past close to enjoy the amazing pizza. Highly recommended!"
8 years ago
Google review
Kimberly Hansen
"Great place with good service #thankyou James."
9 years ago
Google review
"This place is a nice downtown pizza joint to go to. They have good options of pizza and beer. Nice inviting atmosphere."
8 years ago