TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,173 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
Morgan Jade
Dawn Theobald
"Great service"
5 years ago
Google review
Carl Spackler
"Enjoyed it. I'm not crazy about the huge menu and standing there getting a neck ache and blocking up the line from people who know what they want. So my first exposure kinda made the anxiety go crazy. If I was staying around perhaps if learn what I like and don't like. But the spicy version of the flat bread was really good!"
5 years ago
Google review
A. Nelson
"Probably my favorite pizza place in Fargo. "Thee Spicy Pie" is my fav. Tacos are decent, too."
5 years ago
Google review
Tony villoabos
"Not all that!!!"
5 years ago
Google review
Matthew “Ferret” Thompson
"Great pizza good wifi nice people"
5 years ago
Google review
Brandon H
"Very friendly and lovely atmosphere. Amazing food"
5 years ago
Google review
Dustin Milbrath
"We were excited to try this place, the pizza was ok, the grinder was missing several ingredients. The time between the grinder and pizza was very long (over 10 mins) never got napkins, silverware, or was offered water. When we split the bill they split it incorrectly. Had to wait forever for her to bring the bill and went inside to give her cards, then wa..." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
Trina Beninati
"This is the go to spot when dining out for pizza! There are a few locations in Fargo/West Fargo, our favorite is the West Fargo location (but all locations are excellent). They have a huge variety of Pizzas, and I have come to love their salads. They have special sauces you can add to make your pizza more delicious, and offer a selection of adult beverages...." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
A Google User
"We had a very large order for a hockey team. They had the pizzas and food ready on time. The pizza and buffalo wings were very good. Just know the pizzas come with only six large slices so if you want smaller slices you will need to request. Best pizza outside of New York. Restaurant has an industrial feel. Staff friendly .. Senior's discount of 15%"
5 years ago
Google review
Robert Mehring
"Always like this place."
5 years ago
Google review
shea durham
"Ordered pickup. Took longer than what was told by a wide margin."
5 years ago
Google review
Obvious Reasons
"Great service, great pizza, great beer. Not a whole lot else to ask for honestly. Nice patio seating with plenty of inside seating as well."
5 years ago
Google review
Cairn Reisch
"Highly recommend the margarita pizza! We order delivery 2-4 times a month and are never disappointed as their margarita pizza is AMAZING."
5 years ago
Google review
Aaron Burden
"My Top 5 Pizza 🍕 in the Country! Nice bite and spicy pizza with quality toppings!"
5 years ago
Google review
Bryant Bevan
"The no-contact delivery and gluten free options have been great over the last few months allowing the whole family to enjoy great local food while in isolation."
5 years ago
Google review
Chris Anderson
"My first and only time! First they pre make their pizza which means you cant get a pizza without tomato sauce or any other sauce for that matter. 2nd theres cheesy graphitiy everywhere inside. 3red tables are sticky. Yuck. 4th overpriced."
5 years ago
Google review
carl thronson
"I got my info in for free slice of pizza. They wouldn't oner it on may 15. I was goin to buy something else"
5 years ago
Google review
John Tollefson
"Good food"
5 years ago
Google review
J R
"I would rank the pizza here somewhere in the middle of the pack of frozen pizzas. Hands down the worst fresh baked pizza I've ever had. Tacos here are pretty good but if you're a pizza place and your pizzas are that bad, you get one star."
5 years ago
Google review
FE4R THT GUY
"Honestly some pretty legit pizza."
5 years ago
Google review
Jared Solomon
"Denise is the best bartender! And Pearl is amazing, too! Highest recommendation to visit Spicy Pie. Use the app. And the inferno is a world class sandwich!"
5 years ago
Google review
miranda Ortlepp
"I love their wings"
5 years ago
Google review
Kizzia Kulzer
"Amazingggg!"
5 years ago
Google review
Alexis Genareo
"You get your money's worth. Best pizza joint in town"
5 years ago
Google review
"Said that they had NO wings at all. But now she said they WERE OUT of boneless wings only."
4 years ago