TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,231 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
Dylan Hildenbrand
Ben W Gunter
"A little high priced and I expected more, like sauce and toppings to the outside. Very little sauce and toppings bunched in the middle..what a waste"
10 years ago
Google review
Jeff Feller
"I'm a big fan of Spicy Pie. I've eaten at every one of their locations thus far as well. Good food. Since I live in Minot, I've been to this location the most... The staff has really been stellar lately!"
10 years ago
Google review
Jacob Mischel
"This is the second week in a row that my order has been forgotten after 40mins over lunch. It wasn't terribly busy, but I still had to bother the cashier as to where the order was. After she dug through a stack of reciepts, I finally got my food. All in all, the food is great. The service at this location in particular is terrible."
10 years ago
Google review
Jazmin Luna
"Our favorite pizza place !"
10 years ago
Google review
Conveyer Conveyer
"Luke, Rick and Lexi took care of us, even comp'd a few pies that never got picked up. This is a must stop for us whenever we are in Fargo. They will have our business for years to come."
10 years ago
Google review
Jared Evangelista
"Luke, Rick, and Lexie were super awesome. I live all the way out in Michigan and was just passing through. They were nice enough to let us stay a little past close to enjoy the amazing pizza. Highly recommended!"
10 years ago
Google review
Kimberly Hansen
"Great place with good service #thankyou James."
10 years ago
Google review
Theresa beckmann
"Fast service"
10 years ago
Google review
Blake McAllister
"This is hands down the BEST pizza you will ever have."
10 years ago
Google review
Rodney Alley
"by. H b"
10 years ago
Google review
Matthew Gantz
"Hands down this is my favorite take-out pizza place in Fargo. They have some great classics (e.g., pepperoni, sausage, cheese) and soe good unique ones (e.g, the taco pizza). Order by the slice, or get a giant 18-inch pie. Or check out their oddly connected Mexican / sandwich menu. I don't make the rules here; I just follow them."
11 years ago
Google review
Tanya Dietz
"It's DEEE-LICIOUS!!!! We NEED one in Mandan ND, soon!! Great Grinders~Great Tacos~Great Nachos~Desserts~ & Beer... what more is there?!!! YUMMOOO!!"
11 years ago
Google review
David Altschuler
"Get the spicy sauce"
11 years ago
Google review
Nick Post
"I love the food, but the prices have been climbing noticeably for a while. I'm not sure the reasons, but it's not cool."
11 years ago
Google review
Tucker Anderson
"Great Pizza. Bread bites are awesome too!"
11 years ago
Google review
Brenda Hansen
"Waited over an hour and a half for my delivery order. This just pissed me off."
11 years ago
Google review
Nicholas Peckham (Nicko)
"Pizza is not that good which is disappointing because this place is a pizza spot. On the flip side you can get some good deals on slices if you like paying for cheap, low quality pizza."
11 years ago
Google review
Iv Strand
"I like Spicy Pie, don't get me wrong, but for this location I can only give one star for the food. The last couple times I have done a web order to pick up, something was forgotten, which is ridiculous. Once, the peppers were forgotten on my nachos. Fine, I can forgive one mistake. This time I was given a gift card for Christmas, made an online order with..." Read more
11 years ago
Google review
Lucas Brendel
"Twice after ordering a pickup order and showing up after the recommended wait time, I end up waiting after paying 10-15 minutes only to find my order sitting in the heater cart. If it wasn't done when I got there why was I not alerted when it was done, and if it was done before I got there why did no one check the heater cart, leaving me waiting?"
11 years ago
Google review
Nick Nymark
"Excellent Pizza!!!"
11 years ago
Google review
Wanda Barr
"We had a large sausage and pepperoni pizza that was awesome! Thanks"
11 years ago
Google review
Chris Reinemann
"Great food, their pizzas are amazing and so are their desserts. There is also a bar if you are over 21."
11 years ago
Google review
Moira Evanden
"I was very disappointed. I ordered nachoes and a sandwich online. The website gave a projected delivery of 45 minutes and it took more than twice that to arrive. I called the restaurant 4 times and was unable to get anyone to answer the phone to ask what was going on. The delivery boy was very terse. By time I got the food, it was cold. The nachoes were very..." Read more
11 years ago
Google review
Phil White
"2 stars. GREAT FOOD!!! No question about that. Customer service, well, let's just say when your order is incorrect upon delivery it is considered your fault and you will have to argue with "a manager" to get the delivery fee removed in order to get the correct order delivered. It is not like we were trying to get anything free just not charged for their mist..." Read more
11 years ago
Google review
"Sign up for the rewards program. Get a free pizza with a purchase of a pitcher of beer every night from 7 to 11. Worth it. As far as service and the food goes, I've had mixed results. I've been here when the server has forgotten to put in our order, and another time when the cooks just forgot to make our pizza. It's frustrating, but it happens. Most of the..." Read more
10 years ago