TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,231 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
T K
Jordan Anderson
"Super fast and friendly service. The pizza was great with super large portions."
5 years ago
Google review
Tricia Atanasio
"Pick whether you are going to be open or close the whole South Fargo place down, because what you have going on now with open/close and no notice is completely ridiculous."
5 years ago
Google review
Joe Daddio
"It's great fun n delicious n staff is great also always clean n ready to serve..."
5 years ago
Google review
M T
"Thier pisa was good but not anymore."
5 years ago
Google review
Laura Bruns
"A little on the expensive side, but a great place to eat. The pizza is good and the environment is enjoyable. A very relaxing spot in downtown Fargo."
5 years ago
Google review
Ryan Meyer
"Pizza was excellent and the service was quick. My only concern was the cleanliness. My table was sticky even after being wiped off. They should do a deep clean more frequently"
5 years ago
Google review
Anthony Roth
"Grab a supreme you won't be disappointed !"
5 years ago
Google review
Chris Jensen
"The two slice deal is great. It is the next best thing to true NY style pizza from back east."
5 years ago
Google review
L. Rankin
"Italian style pizza!"
5 years ago
Google review
Jim M
"Good pizza and good prices."
5 years ago
Google review
C C
"Edited from 5 star"
5 years ago
Google review
Chris J
"I got excited seeing this place, I love spicy foods. The guy at the counter said the ghost pepper cheese was hot enough on its own, as delicious as it was I didn’t really taste any heat in it. The pizza was good, the staff was helpful, and it was cheap for 2 slices. The only thing I wish was different is the food was spicy (to be fair I have really high hea..." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
Hannah Riley
"Extremely cute cashier took care of everything!! Staff was kind and and place was clean, and of course the pizza was great."
5 years ago
Google review
Victor Toribio
"Great place, great food, clean bathrooms. However you need to get rid of the rice flower crust on the apple dessert pizza that was gross. Use your regular crust with the apple toppings and it would be 100% better and tasty. If you are in Fargo don't miss the opportunity to stop and try it out!"
5 years ago
Google review
Daryl Sager
"Great pizza. One of my favorites."
5 years ago
Google review
monte babe
"Ever since I moved to North Dakota and found their place I haven’t ate at any other pizza place since. I especially like the spicy 🌶 sauce"
5 years ago
Google review
Soy Boy
"I knew what was happening after my very first bite: This place pre-bakes pizzas throughout the day, then refrigerates them and bakes them again as they're ordered. I'm sure the toppings are fresh, but when it comes to pizza you can just taste quality and freshness more than you can with many other foods. I'd say your best bet if you want to eat here would..." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
Robert Tejes
"Get the rewards app. Good deals and free money."
5 years ago
Google review
Raymond Salazar
"Idk why this is a four-star restaurant I’m giving two stars for effort"
5 years ago
Google review
Aziram One
"Fast service, kind employees !"
5 years ago
Google review
Hope Branch
"Order the pizza of the month which was tge blt pizza, also ordered wings and salads. The portions and size are hug, unfortunately there was no flavor at all with the wings and pizza. Actually had to put our own seasoning on the pizza to be able to eat it. Might try it again but order a different pizza."
5 years ago
Google review
Robin Slavik
"Good variety and speedy service"
5 years ago
Google review
Isaac Karlstrom
"Over rated. Just subpar"
5 years ago
Google review
Travis Orth
"I’ve ordered from spicy pie before and it used to be good then it started to go down hill so I stopped ordering from them. So after about a year, tonight I ordered a Mac and cheese pizza and a pepperoni pizza. Let me start of by saying the Mac and cheese pizza was very dry and seemed like it had been sitting for awhile and the Mac and cheese on it was so muc..." Read more
5 years ago
Google review
"Worst pizza I've ever had. Went in, first time ordering here, saw old pizza on racks and commented to my family "look at the old gross pizza" thinking maybe they were for display. Cold congealed cheese, dry, guess what pizza I got..? They are reheated pizzas. They prep them, leave them out, then add toppings and reheat when you order it. The crust was crunch..." Read more
5 years ago