TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,231 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
Colette Erck
Ted Farni
"Food is good. They messed up my order, but went above and beyond to make it right."
a year ago
Google review
Brandon Kasl
"We always go here before a showing at the Theatre because their GIANT slices of pizza are super filling! Parking is somewhat limited, but that's downtown for you, which is why we usually opt for the nearby Mercantile Garage right next to the downtown police substation on the corner of 4th Ave and 5th St. Sometimes the specific slice isn't available right as..." Read more
a year ago
Google review
Zoey Snow
"Friendly staff. Amazing food. And I got to write on the wall. Thank you"
a year ago
Google review
Drew Brovold
"Beat pizza in Fargo"
a year ago
Google review
Aldous Huxley
"Nice folks good food at mall price"
a year ago
Google review
Shayna B
"Caught them right before they closed for the day. It was out first time and my daughter and I just loved it! HUGE slices of pizza and great grinders!"
a year ago
Google review
Zack Putney
"Hadnt been here in many years and was disappointed, there was hardly any meat in my taco grinder, her chicken bacon ranch grinder had hardly any lettuce and could barely taste the ranch, if I'm gonna spend $50 on food I'd like to at least get more than bread for my money."
a year ago
Google review
Matthew Stevens
"Sent here for a delivery and they wouldn't make it"
a year ago
Google review
Martina Shelton
"Absolutely love this pizza"
a year ago
Google review
Jamie Hyatt (Dakota Chasers)
"Great place, good food, cold beer! Patio is a little run down but."
a year ago
Google review
Tammie
"It was great 👍👍👍👍"
a year ago
Google review
Krystal Mclean
"The server was fantastic and worked the whole area, and the food was terrific. Wanted to note that while we were there, the staff was very kind and considerate to an individual with special needs who was there with their caretaker. The server went out of her way to make each group feel uniquely taken care of and appreciated. This can mean the world kids and..." Read more
a year ago
Google review
J Bortnem
"The pizza was delicious and huge! The atmosphere was paid back and fun. The person behind the counter was helpful and knowledgeable but not especially friendly."
a year ago
Google review
That guy that travels a bit
"We ordered a slice of bbq chicken, carnivore, and sausage. The carnivore and sausage honestly tasted like those little square tostinos pizzas from Walmart. Low quality meats and tasted like cardboard. The BBq chicken was good, but it seemed like all were pretty baked, topped, and then rebuked. Staff was ok but not the most inviting. We would not go back..." Read more
a year ago
Google review
Eagle song
"맛있었어요. 분위기도 매우 좋아요"
a year ago
Google review
Nathan Gange
"The pie is great, but why do you start kicking everyone out at 2045, when you close at 2200. Doesn't make sense. Should definitely do better management. You are losing money."
a year ago
Google review
Gamer At Work
"More than just pizza! They have amazing tacos and subs"
a year ago
Google review
Noah Cunningham
"Great pizza by the slice, one plenty for lunch."
a year ago
Google review
Tim Roche
"Worst pizza I have ever eaten. You need some serious help with your dough. Dough was tasteless, soggy and white in color. Toppings were OK, you are an embarrassment to pizza."
a year ago
Google review
John Eaton
"Tried contacting through you site… I went to the fair today the magiccon and I was looking forward to getting some pizza with my little girl. You had one slice of cheese left for her and I asked if another one’s coming out and I was told they’re not gonna put any more out until the other others Have been sold. I would’ve gotten two additional slices that yo..." Read more
a year ago
Google review
Marvin Calice
"The pizza is the closest to New York style you can find around here. Years ago, I loved this place and got pies here all the time. But why pay double for something similar."
a year ago
Google review
Chris Knopik
"Always has been great pizza. This time we got ours to go. Who ever made the pizza's didn't put any sauce on both of our pizza's. We live 80 miles from the nearest Spicy Pie. It was to late to take it back. We will give it one more chance."
2 years ago
Google review
Indigo Hopkins
"Terribly slow service"
2 years ago
Google review
Heather Griffith
"Called in an order while in town visiting and arrived one minute after it was done. Staff were busy talking to each other in the kitchen, even looked up at me, but didn’t say anything. By time I got my pizza it was cold. It was an average pie. Looks like a fun spot to hang out at though! Arcade games for kids and gambling spots for adults"
2 years ago
Google review
"I had a cheese pizza slice and shared nachos. My friend had a sausage pizza slice and garlic Parmesan chicken bites. The food is more like food you would eat while watching a football game than a meal. I had never had the garlic Parmesan chicken bites before and they were delicious. Also a very generous portion size of nachos. There are lots of seats and..." Read more
a year ago