TripAdvisor 
Google 
1,231 reviews
3.9/5 average rating
Stef Bratcher
Tj Reyes
"If you like bread, you'll love it here! They only have one size pizza or you can order slices. They have wings that don't taste very good. They actually taste cheap and very fatty. They have nachos that taste SUPER bland. I guess their beef has never seen spice before. Their pizza is ok. Nothing to write home about. To be called spicy pie and there is nothin..." Read more
3 years ago
Google review
christina weber
"It's a fun drop in and eat quick slice, kinda place. They could really be making hella lot more than what they are if they stayed open later, at least for carry out. Nestled up the street from boss, next door to cowboy jacks and one block from Bismark tavern, everyone says they wish you were the spot that was open late when the bars are closing. I know Boss..." Read more
3 years ago
Google review
San Allen
"The pizza and wings were great this is one of the best spots yet we've ate at I definitely recommend this place"
3 years ago
Google review
Jeff Hayes
"I actually like this place. Very casual. Nice menu. I had the "two-slice with soda" special. $10. I had pepperoni and jalapeno slices. Thin crust. Plenty for me. Glad I went. Nice people."
3 years ago
Google review
brenda kluth
"Absolutely love Spicy pie pizza 🍕, love the thin crust, & your chicken 🐔 tacos , YUM!😋"
3 years ago
Google review
Jam Bitt
"Great big pie. Excellent!"
3 years ago
Google review
Regan Rampage
"A local favorite. Pizza is pretty good, and the atmosphere is nice and relaxed."
3 years ago
Google review
David M
"Pizza was good. Grinder was awesome. They make their nachos differently than a few years ago. The nachos were disappointing and not great. Used to get a pile of chips with toppings in and baked in the oven. Now it is some chips sprinkled on a tray with some toppings melted on."
3 years ago
Google review
Dustin H
"Great pizza as always."
3 years ago
Google review
Dustin
"Awesome place! They had live music outside and they were super busy but we were able to order and get our food super fast! It was delicious"
3 years ago
Google review
Karli Brekke
"Great pizza like always, but wow was it littered with flies and gnats in there. My husband and I couldn’t even sit down for more than a minute without swatting them away. It was pretty frustrating as it didn’t seem like they had a handle on the situation."
3 years ago
Google review
Shana Durdin
"Love being able to order pizza by the slice. We tried several different options and everything was fantastic."
3 years ago
Google review
Seth harstad
"Tried to charge me 3$ for a cup of water . The pizza was disgusting as well. This place use to be good, not anymore though"
3 years ago
Google review
Ross Peterson
"I moved away from Fargo a few years back and I still dream about Spicy Pie. Hot and fresh New York slices with the trifecta of what a good slice should be: generous, flavorful cheese, herby fresh sauce, and crust that cracks when you fold it. It's a miracle if a pizzeria can do two of those things right, but this spot does it all. I can't find anything else..." Read more
3 years ago
Google review
Shauna Kemp-Isbell
"The food was fine but honestly couldn’t get over that I ordered food but the restaurant was to cheap to give me a water cup."
3 years ago
Google review
North American
"Try the PBR Pizza, It's great!"
3 years ago
Google review
Ryan Bergseth
"Just love it in general"
3 years ago
Google review
Nicoh Ross
"I love the food here, but the service is definitely hit or miss. You order something and they bring you something vastly different and make no effort to correct the flaw."
3 years ago
Google review
Sabha Ganai
"I had the most delicious spicy special of the month which had four cheeses and Thai chili sauce. Amazing. Truly delicious."
3 years ago
Google review
Tim Drake
"Fairly decent New York-style pizza served by the pie or by the slice. I like that they serve the slice option. I tried a slice of pepperoni and their cheese curd pizza. Both were good, but not as great as I had hoped for. They also serve grinders and garlic knots and the restaurant also has a bar."
3 years ago
Google review
Hudson Braun
"The pizza is fine, but it came out fast and had great atmosphere."
3 years ago
Google review
sir Flimzak
"Amazing sandwiches, the zeppollis are amazing. Best garlic knots in minot, great prices. Friendly staff. 10/10"
3 years ago
Google review
Ashley Jean
"I love the food and my kiddo ND I love to go and mark our time in history by etching our names on the wall with a sharpie. I love that!! We always look forward to it!"
3 years ago
Google review
Roberto Hendy
"Spicy pie is a favorite when I am on town from my home in mesa. Being able to get a couple slices made to order with my specifications and ability to choose the spicy or regular sauce is one of the reasons I choose to visit every time I am in town. The desert bites dipped in creamy white frosting top off a perfect lunch or dinner. Quaint downtown brick and..." Read more
3 years ago
Google review
"Pretty cool place pizza is delicious!!!"
3 years ago